assignment to constant variable react

TypeError: Assignment to Constant Variable in JavaScript

Last updated: Mar 2, 2024 Reading time · 3 min

# TypeError: Assignment to Constant Variable in JavaScript

The "Assignment to constant variable" error occurs when trying to reassign or redeclare a variable declared using the const keyword.

When a variable is declared using const , it cannot be reassigned or redeclared.

Here is an example of how the error occurs.

# Declare the variable using let instead of const

To solve the "TypeError: Assignment to constant variable" error, declare the variable using the let keyword instead of using const .

Variables declared using the let keyword can be reassigned.

We used the let keyword to declare the variable in the example.

Variables declared using let can be reassigned, as opposed to variables declared using const .

You can also use the var keyword in a similar way. However, using var in newer projects is discouraged.

# Pick a different name for the variable

Alternatively, you can declare a new variable using the const keyword and use a different name.

We declared a variable with a different name to resolve the issue.

The two variables no longer clash, so the "assignment to constant" variable error is no longer raised.

# Declaring a const variable with the same name in a different scope

You can also declare a const variable with the same name in a different scope, e.g. in a function or an if block.

The if statement and the function have different scopes, so we can declare a variable with the same name in all 3 scopes.

However, this prevents us from accessing the variable from the outer scope.

# The const keyword doesn't make objects immutable

Note that the const keyword prevents us from reassigning or redeclaring a variable, but it doesn't make objects or arrays immutable.

We declared an obj variable using the const keyword. The variable stores an object.

Notice that we are able to directly change the value of the name property even though the variable was declared using const .

The behavior is the same when working with arrays.

Even though we declared the arr variable using the const keyword, we are able to directly change the values of the array elements.

The const keyword prevents us from reassigning the variable, but it doesn't make objects and arrays immutable.

# Additional Resources

You can learn more about the related topics by checking out the following tutorials:

• SyntaxError: Unterminated string constant in JavaScript
• TypeError (intermediate value)(...) is not a function in JS

Borislav Hadzhiev

Web Developer

Copyright © 2024 Borislav Hadzhiev

TypeError: Assignment to constant variable when using React useState hook

Abstract: Learn about the common error 'TypeError: Assignment to constant variable' that occurs when using the React useState hook in JavaScript. Understand the cause of the error and how to resolve it effectively.

If you are a React developer, you have probably come across the useState hook, which is a powerful feature that allows you to manage state in functional components. However, there may be times when you encounter a TypeError: Assignment to constant variable error while using the useState hook. In this article, we will explore the possible causes of this error and how to resolve it.

Understanding the Error

The TypeError: Assignment to constant variable error occurs when you attempt to update the value of a constant variable that is declared using the const keyword. In React, when you use the useState hook, it returns an array with two elements: the current state value and a function to update the state value. If you mistakenly try to assign a new value to the state variable directly, you will encounter this error.

Common Causes

There are a few common causes for this error:

• Forgetting to invoke the state update function: When using the useState hook, you need to call the state update function to update the state value. For example, instead of stateVariable = newValue , you should use setStateVariable(newValue) . Forgetting to invoke the function will result in the TypeError: Assignment to constant variable error.
• Using the wrong state update function: If you have multiple state variables in your component, make sure you are using the correct state update function for each variable. Mixing up the state update functions can lead to this error.
• Declaring the state variable inside a loop or conditional statement: If you declare the state variable inside a loop or conditional statement, it will be re-initialized on each iteration or when the condition changes. This can cause the TypeError: Assignment to constant variable error if you try to update the state value.

Resolving the Error

To resolve the TypeError: Assignment to constant variable error, you need to ensure that you are using the state update function correctly and that you are not re-declaring the state variable inside a loop or conditional statement.

If you are forgetting to invoke the state update function, make sure to add parentheses after the function name when updating the state value. For example, change stateVariable = newValue to setStateVariable(newValue) .

If you have multiple state variables, double-check that you are using the correct state update function for each variable. Using the wrong function can result in the error. Make sure to match the state variable name with the corresponding update function.

Lastly, if you have declared the state variable inside a loop or conditional statement, consider moving the declaration outside of the loop or conditional statement. This ensures that the state variable is not re-initialized on each iteration or when the condition changes.

The TypeError: Assignment to constant variable error is a common mistake when using the useState hook in React. By understanding the causes of this error and following the suggested resolutions, you can overcome this issue and effectively manage state in your React applications.

Tags: :  javascript reactjs react-state

Latest news

• Replacing Erroneous Byte 0x9b in Strings: A Simplified Approach
• Creating a Powershell Script to Add Registry Keys with Inconsistent Absence of 'Start-Sleep'
• Understanding the Difference: Generic Method Interface Parameters vs Method Parameters
• Setting Checkbox Column in Datagridview: True Based on Available Values from Database
• Date Format Differences in .NET 4.8 and .NET 8 with CultureInfo 'ar-KW'
• Setting Up Data Insertion from a Select Statement in Supabase
• Summary Function Not Working with CNN for SCIFI10 Image Classification
• Changing AWS Region Dynamically in C#: A Guide for Software Developers
• Error in Creating PySpark DataFrame using PyArrow with float64 type
• Search Inside Collapsed Details Tag Now Automatically Expands in Chrome and Edge
• Excel Conditional Formatting: Make Cells Say 'YES', Turn Green, Otherwise Red
• Displaying Checked Items in a Four-Column ListView using ChecklistBox in Visual Basic
• Firebase Phone Authentication in React Native Applications: Setting up a Cross-Platform Project
• Encountering Gradle Error while Setting Up Flutter Project: Could Not Run Phased Build Action Using Connection
• Firebase App Check Not Verifying Token: A Guide for Docker Container Developers
• Making a Field Nullable: Two-Step Blue-Green Deployments for Database Changes
• Making Class Attributes Private Outside the API, Public Inside
• Sorting Lists of Integers Except Negative Numbers in Java: Achieving the Condition with a Custom Comparator
• Get Razor Page Folder Path in ASP.NET Core 8
• Adjust Height of Gradio Chat Interface Component in Software Development
• What does 'guard let self = self else { return }' mean in Swift and why does it compile successfully?
• Importing Zephyr Project Device Drivers: A Step-by-Step Guide
• Google Identity: Interactive Option for Auth Token Doesn't Work in Chrome Extension
• Reading Attached Object Data Points in DXF using Python's ezDXF Module
• Creating Current Balance DataFrame in PySpark
• Getting Absolute Paths of Files using .NET Core 8 with Vanilla JS
• Styling React Button Component with Custom Class Names
• Sealing Generic Functions: Preventing Additional Methods with DEFGENERIC in Software Development
• Properly Including AAR Files for Cordova Plugins in Ionic/Capacitor Projects
• Automating File Uploads with Robot Framework: A Practical Example
• Understanding Git's core.autocrlf Text Attribute
• Python: Check if Given List Contains Three Consecutive '3's
• Error: 'expression type void value' can't be used. DataScan in Flutter Blue Plus
• MTU Network Device Changes Periodically: How to Fix on a OS X System?
• Avoiding the 'Not Enough Information to Infer Relation' Error in Drizzle ORM Schema with PostgreSQL Many-to-Many Junction Table

Navigation Menu

Search code, repositories, users, issues, pull requests..., provide feedback.

We read every piece of feedback, and take your input very seriously.

Saved searches

Use saved searches to filter your results more quickly.

To see all available qualifiers, see our documentation .

• Notifications You must be signed in to change notification settings

Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.

By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement . We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.

Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account

TypeError: Assignment to constant variable. #16211

lidaof commented Jul 25, 2019

artuross commented Jul 26, 2019 • edited Loading

Sorry, something went wrong.

lidaof commented Jul 26, 2019

jquense commented Jul 26, 2019

artuross commented Jul 27, 2019

shahchaitanya commented Jul 29, 2019

lidaof commented Jul 29, 2019

• 👍 1 reaction

• 👍 3 reactions
• 🎉 2 reactions
• ❤️ 4 reactions
• 🚀 1 reaction

lidaof commented Jul 30, 2019

shahchaitanya commented Jul 30, 2019

prasenpatil2107 commented Oct 10, 2019

• 👍 2 reactions
• 👎 9 reactions

jannunen commented Sep 18, 2021

ghost commented Oct 25, 2021

• 😄 1 reaction

No branches or pull requests

You’ve made it this far. Let’s build your first application

DhiWise is free to get started with.

Design to code

• Figma plugin
• Documentation
• DhiWise University
• DhiWise vs Anima
• DhiWise vs Appsmith
• DhiWise vs FlutterFlow
• DhiWise vs Monday Hero
• DhiWise vs Retool
• DhiWise vs Supernova
• DhiWise vs Amplication
• DhiWise vs Bubble
• DhiWise vs Figma Dev Mode
• Terms of Service
• Privacy Policy

Fixing the Uncaught TypeError: Assignment to Constant Variable in JavaScript

Rakesh Purohit

Frequently asked questions, what does it mean when javascript says "assignment to constant variable", can i change the properties of an object declared with const, is it possible to declare a constant without initializing it, how can i fix the "assignment to constant variable" error.

In the dynamic world of JavaScript development, encountering errors is a part of the learning curve that every developer must navigate. Among these, the "Uncaught TypeError: Assignment to Constant Variable" stands out as a common yet puzzling hurdle. This error not only interrupts the normal execution of your code but also serves as a crucial learning opportunity to understand JavaScript declarations better.

This blog dives deep into the causes of this error, explores solutions, and offers best practices to avoid it in the future, ensuring your development process is smoother and more efficient.

Understanding the Error

What is the "uncaught typeerror: assignment to constant variable".

The JavaScript exception “Assignment to constant variable” occurs when there's an attempt to alter a constant value. Constants, declared using the const keyword, are meant to be a read-only reference to a value. Unlike var or let, constants cannot be re-assigned or redeclared, making them a staple for values that should remain unchanged throughout the execution of a program.

Why does JavaScript throw this exception?

JavaScript enforces the immutability of constants to ensure code predictability and integrity. When a constant variable is attempted to be modified, JavaScript throws this error to signal a breach of its fundamental rules. Consider the following snippet:

This code attempts to re-assign a new value to const x, leading to the mentioned TypeError.

Causes and Solutions

How can assigning a value to the same constant name cause an error.

Assigning a new value to a constant within the same block scope is a direct violation of the const declaration's principle. Block scope, in JavaScript, refers to the area within a function or a block where the variable or constant is accessible. Since const creates a block-scoped variable, any attempt to re-assign its value within the same scope leads to an error.

What does block scope mean in the context of this error?

Block scope is crucial in understanding this error. It delineates the boundaries within which a constant is valid. For instance:

In this example, a is block-scoped within the if statement, and re-assigning it triggers the error.

Strategies to avoid and resolve this error.

To circumvent this error, developers have multiple options:

• Use let for variables that need re-assignment.

• Ensure that constants are not mistakenly re-assigned within their scope.

• Re-evaluate the need for the variable to be a constant if re-assignment is necessary.

Best Practices for Using Const

What does the const declaration imply for variable mutability.

The const declaration creates a read-only reference, meaning the variable identifier cannot be re-assigned. However, if the constant is an object, the object's properties can still be mutated. This distinction is vital for using const effectively without running into the "assignment to constant variable" error.

Guidelines for using const effectively in JavaScript code.

• Use const for all variables that do not require re-assignment.

• Understand the scope of your constants to avoid invalid assignments.

• Remember, const does not make the value immutable, just the variable identifier.

Debugging and Troubleshooting

Steps to identify and fix the "assignment to constant variable" error..

When faced with this error, the first step is to locate the constant that is being incorrectly re-assigned. Review your code to ensure that you are not trying to alter a constant within its scope. Utilizing debugging tools and console logs can help identify the exact line where the error occurs.

Utilizing debugging tools to isolate and resolve the issue.

Modern IDEs and browsers come equipped with powerful debugging tools that can pinpoint where the re-assignment attempt is happening. Breakpoints and step-through execution allow developers to observe the state of their variables and constants at various execution points, making it easier to understand and fix the error.

Understanding and resolving the "Uncaught TypeError: Assignment to Constant Variable" error is a stepping stone towards mastering JavaScript. By adhering to best practices and utilizing effective debugging strategies, developers can ensure their code is robust, error-free, and maintainable.

Short on time? Speed things up with DhiWise!!

Tired of manually designing screens, coding on weekends, and technical debt? Let DhiWise handle it for you!

You can build an e-commerce store, healthcare app, portfolio, blogging website, social media or admin panel right away. Use our library of 40+ pre-built free templates to create your first application using DhiWise.

• Skip to main content
• Skip to search
• Skip to select language
• Sign up for free
• Remember language
• Português (do Brasil)

TypeError: invalid assignment to const "x"

The JavaScript exception "invalid assignment to const" occurs when it was attempted to alter a constant value. JavaScript const declarations can't be re-assigned or redeclared.

What went wrong?

A constant is a value that cannot be altered by the program during normal execution. It cannot change through re-assignment, and it can't be redeclared. In JavaScript, constants are declared using the const keyword.

Invalid redeclaration

Assigning a value to the same constant name in the same block-scope will throw.

Fixing the error

There are multiple options to fix this error. Check what was intended to be achieved with the constant in question.

If you meant to declare another constant, pick another name and re-name. This constant name is already taken in this scope.

const, let or var?

Do not use const if you weren't meaning to declare a constant. Maybe you meant to declare a block-scoped variable with let or global variable with var .

Check if you are in the correct scope. Should this constant appear in this scope or was it meant to appear in a function, for example?

const and immutability

The const declaration creates a read-only reference to a value. It does not mean the value it holds is immutable, just that the variable identifier cannot be reassigned. For instance, in case the content is an object, this means the object itself can still be altered. This means that you can't mutate the value stored in a variable:

But you can mutate the properties in a variable:

React Tutorial

React hooks, react exercises, react es6 variables.

Before ES6 there was only one way of defining your variables: with the var keyword. If you did not define them, they would be assigned to the global object. Unless you were in strict mode, then you would get an error if your variables were undefined.

Now, with ES6, there are three ways of defining your variables: var , let , and const .

If you use var outside of a function, it belongs to the global scope.

If you use var inside of a function, it belongs to that function.

If you use var inside of a block, i.e. a for loop, the variable is still available outside of that block.

var has a function scope, not a block scope.

let is the block scoped version of var , and is limited to the block (or expression) where it is defined.

If you use let inside of a block, i.e. a for loop, the variable is only available inside of that loop.

let has a block scope.

Get Certified!

const is a variable that once it has been created, its value can never change.

const has a block scope.

The keyword const is a bit misleading.

It does not define a constant value. It defines a constant reference to a value.

Because of this you can NOT:

• Reassign a constant value
• Reassign a constant array
• Reassign a constant object

But you CAN:

• Change the elements of constant array
• Change the properties of constant object

COLOR PICKER

Contact Sales

If you want to use W3Schools services as an educational institution, team or enterprise, send us an e-mail: [email protected]

Report Error

If you want to report an error, or if you want to make a suggestion, send us an e-mail: [email protected]

Top Tutorials

Top references, top examples, get certified.

How to define constants in React?

In this article, we explain how to define and use constants in React to make your code more maintainable and reusable.

In React, you can define constants using the const keyword. For example:

This creates a constant named MY_CONSTANT with the value "hello". Constants are like variables, except that their value cannot be changed once they are assigned.

You can use constants in React to store values that don't change, such as configuration options or static data that you want to reference in your code.

Here's an example of how you might use a constant in a React component:

In this example, the constant API_ENDPOINT is used to store the URL of an API endpoint. This constant is then used in the fetch call to retrieve data from the API.

It's important to note that constants in React are only available within the scope in which they are defined. In the example above, the MY_CONSTANT constant would only be available within the MyComponent function. If you want to use a constant in multiple components, you would need to define it in a separate file and import it into the components that need it.

Overall, constants can be a useful tool for organizing and managing your code in React. They can help you avoid hardcoding values and make your code more maintainable and reusable.

November 06, 2022

November 03, 2022

• DSA with JS - Self Paced
• JS Tutorial
• JS Exercise
• JS Interview Questions
• JS Operator
• JS Projects
• JS Examples
• JS Free JS Course
• JS A to Z Guide
• JS Formatter

JavaScript TypeError – Invalid assignment to const “X”

This JavaScript exception invalid assignment to const occurs if a user tries to change a constant value. Const declarations in JavaScript can not be re-assigned or re-declared.

Error Type:

Cause of Error: A const value in JavaScript is changed by the program which can not be altered during normal execution. 

Example 1: In this example, the value of the variable(‘GFG’) is changed, So the error has occurred.

Output(in console):

Example 2: In this example, the value of the object(‘GFG_Obj’) is changed, So the error has occurred.

Similar Reads

• Web Technologies
• JavaScript-Errors

Please Login to comment...

• Noel Tata: Ratan Tata's Brother Named as a new Chairman of Tata Trusts
• Ratan Tata Passes Away at 86: A Great Loss for India and the World
• Uber to launch AI Assistant Back by OpenAI's GPT-4o to help Drivers Go Electric
• 10 Best IPTV Services in Sweden (October 2024 Update)
• GeeksforGeeks Practice - Leading Online Coding Platform

Improve your Coding Skills with Practice

What kind of Experience do you want to share?

Typeerror assignment to constant variable

Doesn’t know how to solve the “Typeerror assignment to constant variable” error in Javascript?

Don’t worry because this article will help you to solve that problem

In this article, we will discuss the Typeerror assignment to constant variable , provide the possible causes of this error, and give solutions to resolve the error.

What is Typeerror assignment to constant variable?

“Typeerror assignment to constant variable” is an error message that can occur in JavaScript code.

It means that you have tried to modify the value of a variable that has been declared as a constant.

Attempting to modify a constant variable, you will receive an error stating:

In this example, we have declared a constant variable greeting and assigned it the value “Hello” .

When we try to reassign greeting to a different value (“Hi”) , we will get the error:

because we are trying to change the value of a constant variable.

How does Typeerror assignment to constant variable occurs ?

This “ TypeError: Assignment to constant variable ” error occurs when you attempt to modify a variable that has been declared as a constant.

In JavaScript, constants are variables whose values cannot be changed once they have been assigned.

If you try to modify the value of a constant variable, you will get the error:

Here is an example :

In this example, we declared a constant variable age and assigned it the value 30 .

If you declare an object using the const keyword, you can still modify the properties of the object.

If you try to reassign a constant object, you will get the error.

For example:

In this example, we declared a constant object person with two properties ( name and age ).

We are able to modify the age property of the object without triggering an error.

If you try to modify a constant variable in strict mode, you will get the error.

In this example, we declared a constant variable name and assigned it the value John .

However, because we are using strict mode, any attempt to modify the value of name will trigger the error.

Now let’s fix this error.

Typeerror assignment to constant variable – Solutions

Solution 1: declare the variable using the let or var keyword:.

Just like the example below:

Solution 2: Use an object or array instead of a constant variable:

If you need to modify the properties of a variable, you can use an object or array instead of a constant variable.

Solution 3: Declare the variable outside of strict mode:

If you are using strict mode and need to modify a variable, you can declare the variable outside of strict mode:

Solution 4: Use the const keyword and use a different name :

Solution 5: declare a const variable with the same name in a different scope :.

But with a different value, without modifying the original constant variable.

You can create a new constant variable with the same name, without modifying the original constant variable.

This can be useful when you need to use the same variable name in multiple scopes without causing conflicts or errors.

So those are the alternative solutions that you can use to fix the TypeError.

Here are the other fixed errors that you can visit, you might encounter them in the future.

In conclusion, in this article, we discussed   “Typeerror assignment to constant variable” , provided its causes and give solutions that resolve the error.

I hope this article helps you to solve your problem regarding a  Typeerror   stating  “assignment to constant variable” .

We’re happy to help you.

Go to list of users who liked

Delete article

Deleted articles cannot be recovered.

Draft of this article would be also deleted.

Are you sure you want to delete this article?

More than 3 years have passed since last update.

【React】TypeError: Assignment to constant variableの対処法

下記ソースを実行したときに、TypeError: Assignment to constant variableが発生してしまいました。 翻訳すると、「TypeError: 定数変数への代入」という内容でした。

定数に対して再度値を代入しようとしていたため、起きていたようです。 useEffect内で代入せず、useStateやuseReduverで値を管理するとよさそうです。

Go to list of comments

Register as a new user and use Qiita more conveniently

• You get articles that match your needs
• You can efficiently read back useful information
• You can use dark theme

React - assignment to constant variable using useState()

I am trying to increment slideIndex  (which is inside useState() hook) on click event but React throws the following error in the console:

I've tried to change useState() from  const to let in my code and it works but I don't think it should be like that:

The problem is that you are trying to increment slideIndex using ++ operator ( ++slideIndex ).

Change  ++slideIndex  to the slideIndex + 1 and it should work.

Your code should look like this:

Native Advertising

Dirask - we help you to, solve coding problems., ask question..

• Stack Overflow for Teams Where developers & technologists share private knowledge with coworkers
• Advertising & Talent Reach devs & technologists worldwide about your product, service or employer brand
• OverflowAI GenAI features for Teams
• OverflowAPI Train & fine-tune LLMs
• Labs The future of collective knowledge sharing
• About the company Visit the blog

Collectives™ on Stack Overflow

Find centralized, trusted content and collaborate around the technologies you use most.

Q&A for work

Connect and share knowledge within a single location that is structured and easy to search.

Get early access and see previews of new features.

Staging Ground badges

Earn badges by improving or asking questions in Staging Ground.

How do I use React setState() to set the state to a specific value that is a constant?

I believe I'm misunderstanding something about how state works in React.js. If I set the above code's setNumber(number + 1) section to '+ 1' like so then number becomes '201' but if I set it to '= newNumber' I get a 'TypeError: Assignment to constant variable' error. Why is this the case? And shouldn't the error be something else since newNumber isn't a constant variable using the 'const' tag?

• react-hooks

• In this case it is much simplier if you use const [number, setNumber] = useState(200) . Also setNumber sets the value for number if you pass as an argument. –  norbitrial Commented Jan 3, 2020 at 12:45
• my initial value has to be something else though. –  Simon Suh Commented Jan 3, 2020 at 12:46

4 Answers 4

The setNumber function accepts a value you want to set your state to. So If you want to set number to the value of newNumber you would do setNumber(newNumber)

Just use setNumber like

or better just in initial expression

Just put your values inside setNumber function.

useState describe the state, it can be an object, string, boolean and a number. In case its a primitive data i.e not an object, you just need to pass the value while updating it as follows:

In case your state is an object, you need to pass the updated state object as follows:

In no case you use = operator.

Your Answer

Reminder: Answers generated by artificial intelligence tools are not allowed on Stack Overflow. Learn more

Sign up or log in

Post as a guest.

Required, but never shown

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service and acknowledge you have read our privacy policy .

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged reactjs react-hooks setstate or ask your own question .

• The Overflow Blog
• Is this the real life? Training autonomous cars with simulations
• Featured on Meta
• Preventing unauthorized automated access to the network
• Upcoming initiatives on Stack Overflow and across the Stack Exchange network...
• Feedback Requested: How do you use the tagged questions page?
• Proposed designs to update the homepage for logged-in users

Hot Network Questions

• SSL certificate working ok on Firefox but not for Chrome
• Relationship between tensor product in Lie algebra and in quantum mechanics
• Do these two sentences have the same meaning? "He's not going to run away. I'll stop him." and "He’s not goin’ to run off if I can stop him."
• Rationale for requiring struct prefix in C
• Why not increase the number of attention heads rather than stacking transformer layers?
• Is there a way to write an AABA lead sheet without writing out the last A section?
• Cryptic simulated voltage in Circuit Lab
• Is grounding an outlet only to its box enough?
• Does painting or staining a fence make it last longer?
• How good is Quicken Spell as a feat?
• Blue Clouds - Dekadoku
• How to test batteries number of cycles (manufacturing quality assurance)
• Why does Jupiter spin so fast but not the Sun?
• For non-native english speakers, is it ok to use chatGPT as a translation assistant?
• Can I give access to my Xbox while prohibiting purchases?
• Prevent ugly hyphenation point in Danish
• Why do evangelicals interpret Heb 4:12 with a meaning that ascribes animacy and agency to a bunch of words?
• Reality Check - How possible is it for a single human to reach "Space Engineers" level of technological prowess?
• Why is my USB 3.0 SD card reader from Amazon being detected as USB 2.0?
• Progressive matrix with circles in/around boxes
• Efficiently combining list elements by matching information
• Any information on the encrypted Knoppix user data file system (knoppix-data.aes)?
• Plane geometry: how to show a moving point with Mathematica
• Why do some nations hold close ties with their former colonies and are there those who don't?