Doing a PhD in Europe vs. the US

Are you thinking of doing a PhD abroad? There are some considerable differences between European and American PhD programs that you should know about before applying. Read on to determine which program is right for you.

Qualifications

It is often not possible to do a PhD in Europe without first earning a Master’s degree. In the US, many PhD programs accept applicants who only have a Bachelor's degree. Students usually earn a Master’s as part of the PhD program after they have completed a few years of coursework and passed certain exams. This doesn't mean that all doctoral candidates in American PhD programs have entered the program straight from undergrad. Several still choose to do a Master’s first before applying for a PhD. In some programs students who already have a Master's might not be required to take as many courses as students with just a Bachelor’s, but this isn't always the case. 

Time to Degree

European PhD programs are shorter than those in the US. For example, it takes three years to complete a PhD in France, Norway, the UK, and Germany. Across Europe, a three to four year PhD in common. In comparison, six years is the average time to degree in the US with many PhDs in the humanities taking seven or eight years to earn their degree.

Thesis Topic

PhD candidates in Europe must choose their thesis topic and supervisor during the application process. Students apply for specific vacant doctoral projects that are usually tied to a professor’s research. As part of their application, they must create a research proposal for this project. It is also possible (in the UK for example) to apply to a department rather than a specific position, but applicants must still include a research proposal and are advised to contact potential supervisors before applying. In the US, candidates apply to a department’s PhD program, rather than a specific PhD project. While they have to discuss their research interests and identify potential supervisors in their applications, students do not decide on their thesis topic until their second or third year. In fact, many science and engineering programs have students rotate between different labs in their first year before deciding on their supervisor and dissertation project.

Teaching Requirement

PhD candidates occasionally have the opportunity to teach in Europe, although teaching is not a requirement in many countries. In the US, PhD candidates are often required to teach undergraduates, often as teaching assistants for a large lecture class. A teaching assistant leads smaller tutorials for 20-30 students and grades their exams and papers. Most PhD students will TA one class each semester for two to three years. Several American PhD programs also have mandatory pedagogy courses for graduate students.

Many European PhD programs require students to do little to no coursework. Candidates start working on their dissertation projects right away. American PhD programs, regardless of the field, require students to take two to three years of courses and seminars about topics across the discipline before they being working on their dissertation.

Funding and Salary

In several European countries, PhD students are seen as employees and have work contracts. As employees, PhD students pay into health insurance, pension, and unemployment insurance. In countries where PhD students are not employees (such as the UK and Italy) students apply for university scholarships, external fellowships, or research grants for funding. Tuition fees are drastically lower in many European countries compared to the United States. Funding at American universities varies widely, as do tuition fees. Private universities have higher tuition than public state schools (though international students usually higher tuition at state schools). The top schools offer five-year funding packages which cover tuition and fees and provide a monthly stipend. They also often include health insurance and conference travel. At other schools, students must compete for fellowships at the university, state, or national level to fund their PhDs. In some departmnets students will be paid and receive partial tuition credit for take teaching assistantship or research assistantship positions.

Comprehensive Exams

Most European PhD programs do not require students to pass qualifying exams to progress through their PhDs. There are some notable exceptions, like Sweden, where PhD candidates do an oral and written exam at the halfway point of their PhD. In the US, students usually have to pass a series of comprehensive exams before they can start working on their dissertation. The exams test the student’s knowledge of the major fields within their discipline. While every university will have a slightly different exam structure, there is usually an oral and a written component. Sometimes students also have to orally defend their dissertation proposal. After the candidate has completed their coursework and passed all the required exams they are considered ABD (all but dissertation).

Discover related jobs

...

Discover similar employers

...

Accelerate your academic career

...

10 Dissertation Writing Tips

The thesis is the capstone of your Master’s or PhD. It’s also an intimid...

...

Moving to Switzerland to Research or Study

Switzerland has a long tradition of attracting international students an...

...

The Academic Career Path in Switzerland

Swiss academic titles are slightly different from their American equival...

...

Moving to Norway to Research or Study

Ready to pack your bags? Here’s our guide to moving to Norway.

...

PhD, Postdoc, and Professor Salaries in France

France has a strong academic tradition and is committed to investing in ...

...

"I found my PhD position on Academic Positions."

When I started looking for positions abroad in Sweden, I came across a p...

Jobs by field

  • Electrical Engineering 193
  • Programming Languages 172
  • Molecular Biology 168
  • Artificial Intelligence 162
  • Machine Learning 156
  • Materials Engineering 145
  • Cell Biology 140
  • Biochemistry 131
  • Computational Sciences 129
  • Materials Chemistry 125

Jobs by type

  • Postdoc 365
  • Assistant / Associate Professor 151
  • Professor 103
  • Research assistant 92
  • Researcher 90
  • Engineer 79
  • Lecturer / Senior Lecturer 61
  • Management / Leadership 55

Jobs by country

  • Belgium 329
  • Netherlands 199
  • Morocco 127
  • Germany 122
  • Switzerland 103
  • Luxembourg 73

Jobs by employer

  • KU Leuven 142
  • Mohammed VI Polytechnic Unive... 131
  • University of Luxembourg 72
  • Eindhoven University of Techn... 67
  • Ghent University 55
  • ETH Zürich 52
  • Leiden University 45
  • Silicon Austria Labs (SAL) 43
  • KTH Royal Institute of Techno... 43

phd in us vs europe

OG_Horizontal.png

Scholarships

Events & Webinars

Course Finder

Universities

Back to all Blogs

challenges of studying abroad

11 Secrets of a PhD in Europe vs USA that Matter

A PHD in Europe or USA?

They’re VERY different!

If you are trying to decide between pursuing a PhD in the USA vs a PhD in the UK, you should think more about which fits you best. There are 11 major differences between the two systems and you need to choose the one that fits you best:

Masters Degree

Typically, in Europe, you would join a PhD program after completing your Master’s degree. In the US, you would spend a few years taking courses (alongside research) to get your Master’s degree.

If you already have a Master’s degree, you may get a course waiver, which could reduce the time needed to complete your PhD.

Most of the US universities ask for GRE and TOEFL in your application for PhD program. But this not mandatory for PhD in europe, including UK and German universities. Though TOEFL, preferably above 90, is highly recommended for international students.

Choose your project before starting your PhD

For PhD in the UK (and Europe) , you need to choose a project before starting your PhD program.

This is different from the US , where you typically apply to a department for your PhD first and your thesis and research evolves in a year or two.

There are no class requirements for a PhD in the UK . You begin your research right away. The assumption is PhD students know their research areas. After all, you start by applying to a professor / lecturer with a research area in mind.

Now, that might be true for some students. Others may want to get exposed to new ideas and potential research topics. In addition, they may also want to have a wider peer group that gets formed in classes.

PhD in US vs Europe: Time to completion

PhD programs in the UK (and rest of Europe) take around 3 to 4 years to complete .

After a PhD in the UK, students generally go on to their postdoctoral research.

In the US , a PhD may take up to 5 or 6 years.

After a PhD in the US , students tend to go directly from graduation to academia or research jobs without a postdoc.

In many UK (and European) universities, there are firm guidelines on just how long a PhD takes and those are more important than individual decisions by a student’s advisers. In comparison, in the US, some students can fly through their PhD in 3 years with tremendous amounts of research, while others can take as long as 8 to 10 years to complete their PhD.

There are different systems within Europe.

In Sweden and other Scandinavian countries, a PhD takes 4 to 5 years and includes additional teaching duties. Students in these schools are considered as employees. They receive monthly salaries which are comparable to the salaries earned by graduate students working in various industries and are taxable as well. A PhD student is allowed to either present or attend at least one conference anywhere in the world, expenses for which are taken care of by the research group.

In Germany, a 4-year PhD is considered too long and funding might not be available after the first three years of the PhD program.

Work-life balance

This point is less about the PhD in question, and more about the cultural difference between the UK (and Europe) and the US, but this could be a factor in your decision making if you are particular about the type of culture around you and the kind of lifestyle you wish to have.

The PhD lifestyle is much more relaxed in the UK (and in Europe). You will have more time for yourself as well as your friends and family in the UK, while pursuing your PhD.

In the US, PhD students are often overworked with more teaching and grading responsibilities. They also have a lot of class work.

PhD in UK vs US: Hierarchical Structure

In the US, PhD students report to and directly interact with their professors, but some of the PhD programs in the UK are headed by the Professor but there is also a Reader and a Lecturer. Students sometimes feel this hampers their flexibility to work, while restricting their exposure to the lab as well as the head of the lab.

Uncover the secrets of a Successful PhD

Seek advice from our counsellors today!

Get important information on Whatsapp

Future opportunities.

Some students feel that the US offers more opportunities to PhD students in academia as well as jobs. This can be true as the US has many universities offering teaching positions as well as companies offering jobs to PhD students.

However, irrespective of whether you earn your PhD from Europe or the US, some experts say you may have to hustle to find a great job after your PhD.

Different Stipend (salary)

For most PhD in the UK (and Europe), stipend (or salary) comes centrally from the universities or from Government research organizations. These stipends (or salaries) may be limited to only 3 years.

In the US , stipend (or salary) comes directly from your supervisor without any limitation on the duration of the PhD. Unlike in big US universities, there are fewer TA responsibilities for PhD students in UK universities.

In many cases, you don’t need to pay tax on your income as a graduate student in the UK (and Europe).

In Germany , international PhD students are funded for 3 years by the German government.

Less Publications

In the UK , you have less chances of getting published . Your time is more focused on your thesis document.

Less Chance of Faculty Position Afterwards

In the US , students opt for faculty positions after receiving their PhD .

This isn’t necessarily the case with PhD students in the UK , who opt for postdoc positions to remain in academia.

Get in Touch with Our Counselors!

More Similarity Than Differences

The UK (and European) universities are being influenced by the US system. Many UK universities’ Computer Science schools have Doctoral Training Programs which are essentially 4-year PhD programs, with the first year focused on teaching. These programs offer more flexibility about what you end up doing and who you end up working with. Also, these programs often are sponsored by industries, which means these have higher stipends and you may get an adviser in industry.

So, which one to choose – UK (or Europe) PhD vs US PhD?

Apart from the factors mentioned above, you should focus on the quality of the research group and reputation of the professor. You should look at the top conferences about your topic of interest and note where the papers come from. That’s your best clue as to which university / school you should choose.

Begin your Overseas Journey with us

Recent blogs.

OG_Horizontal.png

At Azent, we have a strong commitment to education and career development. We are passionate about bringing global education to the doorsteps of students all over India.

Download Azent app

phd in us vs europe

phd in us vs europe

PhD in Europe vs the US: What You Need to Know

phd in us vs europe

All that you need to know before you decide on a university for PhD abroad.

If you’re considering pursuing a PhD, one of the most important decisions you’ll make is where to do it. Two popular destinations for doctoral study are Europe and the United States. In this blog post, we’ll discuss the differences between doing a PhD in Europe and the US, focusing on key factors such as qualification requirements, time to degree, teaching requirements, coursework, and comprehensive exams.

Qualification Requirements: In Europe, a Master’s degree is typically required to enrol in a PhD program, while in the US, a Bachelor’s degree is sufficient. Additionally, European PhD programs often have stricter admission requirements and a more competitive selection process.

Time to Degree: In Europe, PhD programs typically take three to four years to complete, while in the US, they can take longer. This is partly due to differences in program structure, as European programs typically have more focus on research, while US programs include more coursework.

Teaching Requirements: In the US, PhD students are often required to serve as teaching or research assistants to gain practical experience in their field. This is less common in Europe, where the focus is more on research.

Coursework: In the US, PhD programs typically require more coursework than in Europe, with students taking classes in their field of study as well as in related areas. In Europe, the focus is more on research, and students may take fewer courses. To know more about research and coursework needed for PhD abroad  click here.

Comprehensive Exams: In the US, PhD students are typically required to pass comprehensive exams , which test their knowledge in their field of study. These exams are less common in Europe, where the focus is more on the research project itself.

In conclusion, there are significant differences between doing a PhD in Europe and the US, with differences in admission requirements, time to degree, teaching requirements, coursework,  funding, salary,  and comprehensive exams. When deciding where to pursue your PhD, it’s important to consider your personal preferences and goals and to research programs carefully to ensure the best fit for you.

Leave a comment Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Save my name, email, and website in this browser for the next time I comment.

Modal title

phd in us vs europe

YourPedia Global provides the best Online consultancy for Foreign Admission in courses like MS, MEng, PG Diploma, PhD, Post-doc and also helps in writing SOP, Technical essay, Motivation letter, Diversity essay, Cover letter, CV/Resume, Research Proposal, University shortlisting, Professor shortlisting, emails to professors, scholarship and Interview Preparation.

+91-9501773076

General Enquiries

[email protected]

phd in us vs europe

  • GRE General
  • IELTS Academic
  • Find a course

Our Company

  • Our Results
  • Testimonials

Study Abroad

  • Study in UK
  • Study in Canada
  • Study in USA
  • Study in Australia
  • Study in Newzealand
  • Study in Germany
  • Study in Ireland

Other Links

  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms & Condition

Copyright © 2023 , All rights reserved.

phd in us vs europe

Welcome to YourPediaGlobal, where we turn dreams into passports and ambitions into boarding passes.

Our team is here to support you at every step, ensuring your experience is not just educational but truly transformative.

Phone Number (required)

phd in us vs europe

View the latest institution tables

View the latest country/territory tables

8 big differences between the US and UK PhD experience

And one important similarity. 

Helen Robertson

phd in us vs europe

Credit: Malte Mueller/Getty

And one important similarity.

11 March 2020

phd in us vs europe

Malte Mueller/Getty

In 2019, I took a risk by moving halfway around the world as a postdoctoral researcher in molecular evolution.

Since then, I’ve been struck by how different the grad school experience is here at the University of Chicago in the US, compared with my time at the University College London in the UK, where I completed my PhD in 2017.

Here’s what I’ve noticed:

1. UK grad school interviews are shorter and more lab-specific

In the UK, you’re likely to apply directly to a lab for an advertised project or one that you develop with your supervisor.

In the US, the application process is more centralized. You usually apply to a school instead of a lab. Some programs even require you to take a standardized Graduate Entry Program test, though this seems to be on the decline .

Grad school interviews in the US tend to be longer. They can involve a series of interviews, tours, and faculty events over a number of days.

2. In the US, a work-life balance is harder to achieve

I’ve been surprised by how all-encompassing a US doctorate can be. Even after the first year of teaching, the number of seminars, journal clubs, and university-related activities make the US PhD experience very grad school-centric.

I was fortunate during my UK-based PhD to approach it more like a full-time job than a continuation of my masters year. There were intense periods that required late nights in the lab, but I had time to pursue other interests , which provided some balance and made me more productive at work.

Of course, it’s difficult to generalize about working patterns. Demanding schedules are not wholly dictated by the country you’re studying in. A recent study found that 76% of surveyed grad students spent more than 41 hours a week on their project.

3. It takes longer to complete a PhD in the US

Probably the best-known difference is the time it takes to complete a PhD.

UK PhD programs tend towards three years in length, although it’s increasingly getting closer to four years – a trend that might soon be reflected in funding arrangements .

It’s a different story in the US, where, according to the Survey of Earned Doctorates , students take an average of 5.7 years to graduate.

4. UK PhD fees tend to be lower

Fees err on the more expensive side in the US, as they do for undergraduate degrees – although this isn’t always true for international students.

US PhD fees, coupled with the longer study time, means that the costs associated with grad school are generally higher than in the UK, even before living costs are considered.

If you have a funding body attached to your project, it will likely pay your tuition fees as part of its finance package. But this flags a major difference between the two countries: funding and scholarships.

5. Many US students need to apply for their own funding

From my understanding, most advertised science-based PhD projects in the UK are attached to funding, which covers tuition fees, bench costs, and living expenses. The tax-free PhD stipend set by all UK Research Councils is £15,285 (approximately US$20,000), although other funding bodies pay more.

In the US, there is no national funding level – your level of financial support will be dictated by your school or lab. This means there is generally much more encouragement for US PhD students to apply for their own funding than there is in the UK.

This is good experience for a future scientific career, but if you have to work additional hours to supplement scholarships, you’ll ultimately end up with less time for your project.

6. US PhD programs are more structured

This is particularly true in the first year for US PhDs, which includes lectures, exams, and lab rotations. Only at the end of the first year, after passing your qualifying exam, do you have the opportunity to pick the lab you’re going to pursue your PhD research in.

In the UK, I started in the lab that I spent the duration of my studies in. This meant no structured classes or rotations in my first year, and I began my own research right away.

PhDs that are run through a Doctoral Training Centre (DTC) – centres that manage the Research Council-funded PhD degrees – are increasingly popular in the UK, and include classes and rotations during the first year, but often without the frequent exams and coursework that characterize grad school in the US.

7. There is more focus on defending your thesis in the UK

Writing my thesis was the final hurdle of my UK PhD experience. It gave me the opportunity to document my ideas, successes (and failures), and the context of my project. I defended my thesis in a closed session with two examiners: one internal to my institution, and one external.

From what I’ve seen, finishing a doctorate in the US is less focused on a thesis. Instead, your committee determines that you have completed sufficient work and skill attainment to warrant your defense. Only then can you write your thesis, and defend it in a public session.

In the UK, it’s unlikely you’ll know your examiners well, but a US PhD defense is assessed by the same thesis committee that have known you for the duration of your studies.

8. Teaching is an added bonus in the UK

My UK PhD funding set no teaching requirements: instead, I was free to teach labs and mark coursework at the discretion of my supervisor. And I was paid for any teaching hours I did.

Teaching requirements in the US vary from school to school. For some students, working as a teaching assistant is necessary to pay fees and living expenses – particularly if you don’t have comprehensive funding.

There might also be minimum teaching requirements for the duration of your PhD in the US. In this respect, the time commitment and financial compensation of teaching is very institution-specific.

One important similarity: The lab you join will determine your experience

Despite the differences in structure and requirements between UK and US PhDs, one thing that is common to them all is that, ultimately, your PhD is going to be shaped by the lab you decide to join.

If have a positive working environment and appropriate guidance and support from your supervisor, and you’re interested in and motivated by your thesis topic, then your grad school experience will likely be rewarding.

And that’s true regardless of the country you’re studying in.

Sign up to the Nature Index newsletter

Get regular news, analysis and data insights from the editorial team delivered to your inbox.

  • Sign up to receive the Nature Index newsletter. I agree my information will be processed in accordance with the Nature and Springer Nature Limited Privacy Policy .

Subscribe to Updates

Get the latest creative news from FooBar about art, design and business.

By signing up, you agree to the our terms and our Privacy Policy agreement.

10 Time Management Tips for Older PhD Students Who Want to Balance Work and Studies

Breaking barriers: empowering black women over 40 to excel in information systems phd programs. , the top 8 must-know tips for phd preparation: how to get started.

PhD  Information

Comparison of European And US-based PhD Education

Obi

What is the difference between getting a PhD Education in the US versus a European? What are the pros and cons of each? This blog article will help you answer these questions by providing helpful insights.

The Differences between US and European PhD Education.

The continents and countries that offer the best value may depend on several factors as well as your personal preferences. Which is one is best is a difficult question to answer, as each country has different tuition fees, research opportunities, and job prospects.  I highlight the differences using the following key areas. You decide as you read through.

  • Application process
  • Tuition and funding
  • Structure of education
  • Course work requirements
  • Teaching requirement
  • Comprehensive exam
  • Publication requirements
  • Time to complete

The application process for US-based vs. Europe PhD education  

Master’s Requirement:

In the US, depending on the area of focus (i.e., engineering, business), there may not be a requirement for a master’s degree before applying for a Ph.D. program. For example, Engineering Ph.D. programs do not require a master’s degree. However, some universities may bundle the Master’s degree requirements into the Ph.D. program. Most business schools in the US require a master’s degree before applying for a Ph.D. program. In Europe, there is a requirement for a Master’s degree.

Research Proposal:

In Europe, as part of the application process, prospective students must submit a research proposal with their application. This means that students are required to already know what they want to research for the Ph.D .

In the US, however, there isn’t a requirement to submit a research proposal.  Phew. This requirement would have disqualified me because I sure did not have a clear idea of what I wanted to study before I applied. I just knew the general area and wanted to learn all there was to know about that area. However, I could not have been able to articulate it in a research proposal at the time. I didn’t even know what a research proposal looked like.

Funding and tuition for US-based vs. Europe Ph.D. education 

Many European universities offer financial assistance for PhD education of students. Many have detailed information on how they fund, where the funding comes from, and the cost-of-living expenses. For example, on the University of Manchester’s website , you will not have to spend too much time searching to find information about their funding and commitment to funding.

In the US, the equivalent is also the case. However, it is more difficult to find information about their funding. When I was looking for a PhD Education program, I thought I was going to fund myself because this information was not clear to me. Some universities do better at marketing and explaining their funding opportunities than others. I think they should do more to make this information readily available and clear to prospective students.

By and large, I find that schools in the UK are more upfront about informing prospective students of their funding opportunities than schools in the US.

The average cost of obtaining a Ph.D. in the US is $120,000 (for four years), while in Europe, it is £38,600. This means that the US university system is more expensive than in Europe. But remember that most of this cost is funded by the university.

Structure of education for US-based vs. Europe Ph.D. education 

In the US, the 2-year period reserved for coursework does three main things. (1) It gives the student plenty of time to understand how the program works. (2) It also allows students to build relationships with potential advisors and understand their strengths and weaknesses, (3) It gives the student time to figure out a topic of interest to research. At the end of the 2 years is when students are supposed to write their Research Proposal.

In most European-based schools, the Research Proposal is required up front as an application requirement. Also, if an advisor with similar interests and capacity is available, the student is attached to an advisor. The advisor starts to work with the student to fine-tune the student’s research proposal and build upon it. This usually means that a student is only admitted to the program if there is an advisor available to supervise the student.

Course work requirement for US-based vs. Europe Ph.D. education 

US-based PhD Education programs have a 2-year coursework requirement. This means that when you start your program, you take classroom-based courses for 2 years so you learn how to do research and more especially how to quantitatively analyze data. In most European schools, coursework is not a requirement. They often do not have formal classroom-based coursework that makes it into a transcript.

This could potentially be a problem for European-trained PhDs seeking to move to the US. This is especially the case for early-career Ph.Ds., who do not yet have a history of publications. You see, these publications are evidence showing that one knows how to do research. Without the publication evidence or the transcripts that show that one took coursework, how are prospective schools assured that you can do good research?  

Publication requirement for US-based vs. Europe PhD education 

In the US, most universities expect doctoral candidates to publish at least one article in a peer-reviewed journal during their tenure as graduate students. This requirement can be a challenge for those unwilling to spend countless hours working on projects. However, it also allows students to develop strong research skills. European PhDs tend to have fewer research and publication expectations, and many programs do not require students to publish papers during their time as graduate students.

Time to complete a Ph.D. in a US-based vs. Europe PhD Education program 

The duration for completing a PhD education is similar in both locations. In the US, the average is 4 years for a full-time program. In the UK, it is also an average of 4 years for full-time programs. Students can do it in longer or shorter times. I completed mine in 4 years, and I know a few colleagues who did theirs in 3-years. Doing it in 3 years requires not just a lot more dedication; it also requires the full support of one’s advisor. If the advisor is not in support or not capable of pushing one through, it becomes a lot more improbable. 

Your current location

If your current location is in the US or Europe, then sometimes, where you pursue your PhD education boils down to your current location. The question of choice between the US and Europe could be something that only international students make.

I am based in Texas, US, and my choices were limited to the universities in a 50 – 100 mile radius. That’s it. I had family obligations that made it so, and I am happy that were constraints. Otherwise, the limitless choices would have even complicated my decision to pursue it in the first place.

By and large, figure out what’s important to you and stay within that framework.   

Regarding doctoral education, there are a few key differences between European and US-based programs. I hope this article provides an overview of the two systems, highlighting some of their differences. It is important to remember that no two places are alike, so if you’re looking for a specific type of doctoral program or environment, you’ll likely succeed more by identifying what’s important to you as you compare.

' src=

Related Posts

Discover the perks of traveling to academic conferences: forget networking and focus on connecting , you’ve decided to pursue a phd in your 40s – now, what, how to choose a phd business concentration, how much does a phd in business make, phd recommendation letters.

Save my name, email, and website in this browser for the next time I comment.

Type above and press Enter to search. Press Esc to cancel.

phd in us vs europe

  • PhD in USA – A Guide for 2024/25
  • Finding a PhD

A PhD in USA takes approximately 5 – 6 years of full-time study and can cost between $12,000 – $45,000 per academic year. PhD programs in USA differ from that in the UK and Europe in that students must first take taught classes, coursework and exams before starting their research project.

Why Do a PhD in USA?

The United States has long had some of the most distinguished universities and advanced PhD programmes in the world. Combined with curriculum flexibility, rigorous teaching methods, vast funding opportunities, breathtaking campuses and significant career prospects, it’s no wonder that it is one of the most sought-after study destinations for research students.

In addition to comprehensive training standards, here are a few other reasons why a student may choose to undertake their PhD in the United States:

  • Longer learning timeframes – A PhD in the US lasts longer than a PhD in the UK or Europe. This allows students to more confidently transition from undergraduate to postgraduate studies; more commonly referred to as ‘graduate studies’ in the US. This gives you the opportunity to learn more about your subject, research methods and academic writing in general before starting your research project.
  • World-class universities – It’s no secret that some of the most well-known higher education institutions that continue to dominate global rankings are based in the United States. Although many factors go into determining whether a position is right for you, a PhD at a high-ranking American university will undeniably have many benefits, from excellent learning standards to access to innovative equipment and deep expertise.
  • International network – The US has long been a popular choice among PhD students around the world. As such, the US hosts a diverse and multicultural learning environment in which many research students will quickly feel at home.
  • Opportunities – With over 4,000 universities in the US, we can safely say you will have plenty of opportunities to find the ideal combination of project, supervisor and university that works for you.

Universities in USA

Universities in the United States can be divided into two types: public universities and private universities.

Public universities are financed by the state in which they are based. Because of this, public universities charge less for students from within the state and more for students from outside the state, including international students.

Private universities are not financed by their state, but by private donors, research funds and tuition fees. For this reason, private universities generally charge higher tuition fees than public universities and require all students to pay the same amount, regardless of whether they come from out-of-state or abroad.

According to the Times Higher Education World University Rankings 2024 , eight of the top ten universities in the world are located in the United States. These are:

1 UK University of Oxford
2 USA Stanford University
3 USA Massachusetts Institute of Technology
4 USA Harvard University
5 UK University of Cambridge
6 USA Princeton University
7 USA California Institute of Technology
8 UK Imperial College London
9 USA University of California, Berkeley
10 USA Yale University

Method of Study

The main difference between a PhD in the US and a PhD in Europe lies in the program structure. Whereas a European PhD essentially consists of a single phase lasting three to four years , an American PhD consists of three different phases, each with its own time frame.

  • Phase One – The first phase lasts approximately two years and focuses on building a basic foundation for the doctoral student. This phase consists largely of taught components such as lectures, tutorials and laboratory sessions, in which the student learns more about theoretical concepts and research methods within their discipline.
  • Phase Two – The second phase can be considered an assessment phase, which runs both periodically alongside and at the end of the first phase. Here, students complete coursework and take exams on the basis of the material they have covered of which they must pass in order to proceed to the third phase.
  • Phase Three – The third phase lasts approximately three years and resembles the European PhD structure. During this period, the student undertakes an independent research project, including forming a research design, conducting experiments, writing a thesis (more commonly referred to in the USA as a dissertation) and sitting a viva exam.

Teaching Requirements

Besides structure, a key difference between a PhD program in the US and in Europe is the focus on teaching requirements. In the US, doctoral students are expected to lecture, lead tutorials, host laboratory sessions, mark coursework and provide office hours for undergraduate students. Although students studying in European will likely contribute to these at some point during their study, this would normally be on a voluntary basis and involve less time commitment.

Research Flexibility

Another difference is project flexibility. In Europe, students typically apply to a PhD project predetermined by a supervisor, and although there may be some scope to adapt the project, depending on the funding provider , it will usually be limited to how the project is carried out rather than what it is about. In the US, however, a student applies to become a doctoral candidate within a department rather than applying for a particular research project. This is because students are expected to decide on their thesis topic (also commonly referred to as a dissertation research topic) near the end of their first phase after they have developed a better understanding of their subject and know where their interests lie. Therefore, research students in the US generally have more flexibility and influence in the direction of their research than students in the United Kingdom or Europe.

PhD Admission Requirements in USA

PhD admission into US universities can be highly competitive, both because of the limited number of positions and the large number of annual applicants.

The eligibility requirements for a doctoral program in the USA can generally be divided into four sections:

How to Apply for a PhD in USA

  • Grade Point Average ( GPA ) – in the US, a scoring system known as Grade Point Average is used to measure academic ability. A student’s GPA is calculated as a weighted score of the subjects they study during their undergraduate degree; an equivalent score is calculated by universities for international applicants. Although universities rarely set minimum GPA requirements for doctoral study, it’s worth being aware that a GPA of 3.0 is equivalent to a UK second class honours (2:1); the typical entry requirement for UK universities.
  • Graduate Records Exam (GRE) – most universities will require you to take a series of examinations known as Graduate Records Exams, which are used to determine your suitability for graduate study. GREs will assess your analytical, reasoning and critical thinking skills as well as your depth of your subject.
  • Student aptitude – in addition to academic ability, US universities also look for characteristics of a strong researcher. These include traits such as engaging in the subject in your own time, e.g. by attending talks and conferences, demonstrating a high degree of independence and enthusiasm, and a general passion for your subject.
  • English Language Proficiency – international students whose first language is not English must sit language exams such as IELTS or TOELF to demonstrate their English language proficiency.

International students will also require a F1 student visa in order to study in the US, however, you would typically apply for this after you have secured a place into a doctorate program.

How to Apply for PhD in USA

When applying for a PhD position at a graduate school, the application process will differ between universities, however, they will all typically ask for the following:

  • Academic CV – a short document summarising your educational background and current level of experience .
  • Personal statement – a document which outlines why you believe you are suitable for PhD study and your passion for the subject.
  • Academic transcripts – a complete breakdown of the modules and their respective marks you have taken as part of your previous/current degree.
  • GRE scores – a transcript of your Graduate Records Exam results.
  • Research statement – a condensed version of a research proposal outlining your general research interests, if required.
  • Recommendation letters – references from several academic referees who endorse your qualities as a person, your abilities as a student and your potential as a doctoral researcher.

Application Deadlines and Fees

Since PhD programs in the United States have taught components, they commence at the same time as all other taught degrees, and therefore share the same application deadlines and start dates. This corresponds to an application period that typically begins in August and ends in February. Admission decisions are typically made in April, with successful students starting in August/September.

When you apply to a graduate school, you will be expected to pay a fee for each doctorate application to cover the school’s administrative costs for processing your application. The fee varies from university to university, but typically ranges from $50 to $100 .

Funding your PhD in USA

It’s very common for a PhD student to receive financial aid in the form of a PhD scholarship; in fact, this will be the case for the vast majority of students in the US.

PhD funding can be ‘fully funded’ covering the student’s graduate program tuition fees, accommodation and living costs, or ‘partially funded’ covering the student’s tuition fee only in part or full.

Besides funding, a graduate student can take on an assistantship, such as a graduate teaching assistant or research assistant, in which they take on a part-time salaried position at the university alongside their studies.

Due to the international and collaborate nature of American universities, there are also a number of international scholarships available, such as the Fulbright Scholarship and the AAUW International Fellowship .

PhD Duration in USA

In the US, a PhD takes approximately 5 – 6 years to complete if studying full-time, and 8 – 10 years if studying part-time.

If you already have a Master’s degree, your first phase can be shortened by one year at the discretion of the university.

Cost of a PhD in USA

The cost of a PhD program in the US can vary considerably depending on the type of university, i.e. whether it’s a public or private university, the doctoral course, i.e. whether it’s in a STEM subject such as computer science, engineering or a non-STEM subject, and whether you are a home or international student.

In general, however, the typical annual tuition fee for a PhD in the US is between $12,000 and $45,000 per academic year.

As with any doctoral degree, additional costs may include travel for collaborations, bench fees, accommodation and living expenses.

Browse PhDs Now

Join thousands of students.

Join thousands of other students and stay up to date with the latest PhD programmes, funding opportunities and advice.

Embarking on a PhD Journey in the USA: A Guide for Aspiring Scholar

Category: US vs Europe PhD

Comparing stem phd requirements: us vs europe.

Comparing STEM PhD Requirements: US vs Europe

Understanding the differences in STEM PhD requirements between the US and Europe is crucial for aspiring researchers. This article aims to provide a clear comparison of these varying academic landscapes, helping students make informed decisions about their educational paths. Key Takeaways Details Educational Background US typically requires a Bachelor’s degree, Europe a Master’s degree Program…

Applying to STEM PhD Programs: European Students to the US and US Students to Europe

Applying to STEM PhD Programs: European Students to the US and US Students to Europe

European Students Applying to US Programs European students interested in pursuing a STEM PhD in the United States should start by researching universities and programs that align with their academic interests and career goals. The application process generally involves: US Students Applying to European Programs For US students applying to European STEM PhD programs, the…

  • Assistant Professor / Lecturer
  • PhD Candidate
  • Senior Researcher / Group Leader
  • Researcher / Analyst
  • Research Assistant / Technician
  • Administration
  • Executive / Senior Industry Position
  • Mid-Level Industry Position
  • Junior Industry Position
  • Graduate / Traineeship
  • Remote/Hybrid Jobs
  • Summer / Winter Schools
  • Online Courses
  • Professional Training
  • Supplementary Courses
  • All Courses
  • PhD Programs
  • Master's Programs
  • MBA Programs
  • Bachelor's Programs
  • Online Programs
  • All Programs
  • Fellowships
  • Postgraduate Scholarships
  • Undergraduate Scholarships
  • Prizes & Contests
  • Financial Aid
  • Research/Project Funding
  • Other Funding
  • All Scholarships
  • Conferences
  • Exhibitions / Fairs
  • Online/Hybrid Conferences
  • All Conferences
  • Career Advice
  • Study Advice
  • Work Abroad
  • Study Abroad
  • Campus Reviews
  • Recruiter Advice
  • Teaching Advice Articles
  • INOMICS Educator Resources
  • INOMICS Academy
  • INOMICS Study Guides
  • Economics Terms A-Z
  • University / College
  • Graduate / Business School
  • Research Institute
  • Bank / Central Bank
  • Private Company / Industry
  • Consulting / Legal Firm
  • Association / NGO
  • All EconDirectory
  • 📖 INOMICS Handbook

All Categories

All disciplines.

  • Scholarships
  • All Economics Terms A-Z
  • EconDirectory
  • All 📖 INOMICS Handbook

phd in us vs europe

Student Experiences

5 key differences between american- and european-style phd programs.

Read a summary or generate practice questions using the INOMICS AI tool

A PhD is a life choice. One of the crucial factors that a potential graduate student should account for is that doing a PhD in the US can be a completely different experience from doing a PhD in Italy, Germany, or elsewhere in Europe.

This piece primarily focuses on the differences and similarities between economics PhD programs on the two sides of the Atlantic. I later discuss how an economics PhD is organized in other parts of the world, as many other countries have modeled their PhD programs on one of these two styles.

Program duration

The most striking difference between an American and European economics PhD is the expected duration of the program.

In the US, universities traditionally offer a five-year degree where the first two years are devoted to training, and the final three years are expected to be spent on independent research. At the end of Year 1, graduate students take core examinations to progress to the second year. These are traditionally in Microeconomics , Macroeconomics and Econometrics . In the second year of an American PhD, students can choose courses that are closer to their research interests, which allows them to specialize in a particular field.

In Europe, graduate programs vary significantly in terms of both structure and expected study duration. A standard Economics PhD lasts three to four years. In the first year, graduate students typically follow PhD-level courses offered by their department and develop a research proposal. The next two to three years are spent on independent research.

Recently, many top European economics schools have started offering a 5-year PhD program following the American tradition. It is composed of two years of intensive classes delivered ‘in-house’ by the respective department, after which students are typically awarded a degree of a Research Master’s (or MPhil) and progress onto the research stage.

Some universities offer a three-year ‘research only’ program for more advanced students, although this is still uncommon. These programs are usually for students that completed a Research Master (or an MPhil) somewhere else or gained extensive research experience prior to their PhD.

phd in us vs europe

Master’s degree requirements

The second difference between an American and a European PhD is whether one can apply with an undergraduate or a Master’s degree.

Most economics departments in the US have a preference for candidates with a completed Master’s degree. However, this is not usually a formal requirement: many successful applicants get in with an undergraduate degree and no or limited prior research experience. To strengthen their portfolio, especially when applying to top schools, some applicants spend a year or two as a predoctoral fellow ( “predoc” ) at a reputable department.

Suggested Opportunities

  • PhD Program
  • Posted 4 weeks ago

Centre for Health Economics, Monash Business School- PhD Program

Logo for Centre for Health Economics, Monash University

  • PhD Program, Supplementary Course, Program
  • Posted 1 month ago

Ph.D. Supplementary Courses

Logo for Kiel Institute for the World Economy (IFW)

PhD Research Opportunity - The Economics of Preventing Future Health Inequalities

Logo for

Research flexibility

American and European doctoral programs also differ in the degree of flexibility that the students get when choosing their research topic.

In the US, a doctoral dissertation is a composition of several (typically, 3-4) research papers that might or might not be interconnected. They can even come from different fields in economics and demonstrate a diversified portfolio for a future PhD holder. A job market paper, which is chosen from the research portfolio and is usually the most promising and advanced piece of research, plays a far greater role for someone who wishes to pursue an academic career. This is because those pursuing an academic career will be required to submit a single paper for presentation at an annual American economics job market event, where recent PhD graduates are matched with academic institutions. The process is highly centralized in the US by the American Economic Association (AEA).

European PhD students typically develop an elaborated research proposal prior to commencing an active research stage. The projects (typically 3-4) are expected to be interlinked and within one research field.

In striking contrast to the US, many departments in Europe and the UK offer project-based PhD positions. That is, a professor (or a research group) submits a grant proposal on a specific topic to the national or European research council. If the application is successful, the allocated funds are used to cover the compensation of everyone involved: from research assistants and PhDs to postdoctoral researchers and principal investigators. Typically, several PhD students are recruited for one project. As the research topic is predetermined by the project, students have little flexibility to work on something else. This form of doctorate studies is rare in America.

Funding opportunities

Funding sources and opportunities for PhDs are another striking difference.

phd in us vs europe

In America, PhD funding is typically a complex composite. The funds come from various sources: the graduate school, the department, or a dedicated charity or national fund. The form of funding varies, too: from teaching and research assistantships to merit-based scholarships. The final amount might vary from year to year and depends on the student’s individual circumstances.

In Europe, a PhD scholarship is usually a fixed amount offered for the duration of the program. Additional funds may come from teaching and exam invigilation activities (the latter being particularly common in the UK). The funds are allocated by the university or the department. For those pursuing a project-based PhD (see the previous section), the funds come from the sponsoring body and are administered by the department.

Moreover, in Europe, it is common to do an externally funded PhD: a company or an organization (such as a ministry, a national central bank, or a think tank) sponsors the doctoral degree for their (future) employee to research a very particular topic that is relevant for them. This is usually done in collaboration with a university, but the expenses are covered by the respective stakeholder.

Teaching expectations

Both American and European PhD programs offer significant exposure to teaching.

In America, teaching duties are not only an essential part of economics PhD training but also a source of funding in most cases. Teaching at both undergraduate and Master’s levels is considered a crucial element of a successful academic job market preparation for graduate students.

In Europe, the amount of teaching workload depends on the program and institution. In a standard 4-year PhD track, students spend on average 15% of their time on teaching. Project-based and externally funded PhD students are typically not expected to teach any classes, but the department usually provides the opportunity to do so at the student’s will. In the UK, for instance, PhD students can choose how many hours to teach: this work is paid on top of the base PhD scholarship.

How it works in other parts of the world

Universities in Australia, New Zealand and Canada typically follow the American PhD structure: two years of classes plus three years of independent research. A PhD experience there is comparable to the one in the US. Similar programs (in terms of organization) are offered by top Asian schools in Hong Kong, Singapore, and South Korea.

In other parts of the world, where economics research capacities are less developed, doctoral studies take various forms, such as employment at the national academy of sciences.

phd in us vs europe

My experience of choosing a PhD

I applied for 7 PhD programs in both the US and Europe and got offers from 4. I personally opted for a Dutch 3-year program. From day one, I have focused on the research project that I started during my Research Master’s degree. The university also offered me the chance to take on teaching and supervision responsibilities from the first year.

My choice involved a trade-off, too: as I am not part of an established project and came with my own idea that had been partially carried out elsewhere, I had to accommodate more risks related to my research output. For example, I had to prove that my research idea fit the department’s agenda or that, as a newcomer to the faculty, I would be able to finish the chapters on time. But those concerns were swiftly managed thanks to the collaborative relationship that I built with my supervisors.

If you’re in the position that I was, and you already have a Master’s degree, a developed research idea, or some prior research experience, a 3-year or 4-year program in the European style can be an appealing option. But, for those students who don’t yet feel confident in their academic background but are committed to the PhD path, an American-style 5-year program can offer a great starting point.

Header and article image credits: Pixabay.

INOMICS PhD in economics guide

Currently trending in Russia

  • Postdoc Job
  • Posted 3 weeks ago

PostDoc Researcher at UNU-MERIT (modeling): inequality impacts of the green and digital technology

Logo for Maastricht University

  • Posted 1 week ago

18th South-Eastern European Economic Research Workshop, 19-20 November 2024, Tirana, Albania.

Wits global fintech conference.

Logo for University of the Witwatersrand

  • economics phd
  • student experiences
  • study abroad
  • Hanna Sakhno
  • studying abroad

Related Items

PhD Student (m/f/d) in health economics and/or development economics

PhD Student (m/f/d) in health economics and/or development economics

Call for Research Projects 2024 “Women and Science”

Call for Research Projects 2024 “Women and Science”

 International Doctoral Courses and Seminars in Health Economics and Policy

International Doctoral Courses and Seminars in Health Economics and Policy

Featured announcements, 36th rsep international conference on economics, finance and business, rsep & srh dresden school of management international conference on…, university of glasgow adam smith business school, 2024 asia-pacific conference on economics and finance ‘live’ (apef….

  • scholarship

Upcoming Deadlines

  • Aug 15, 2024 Master of Science in Health Economics
  • Aug 15, 2024 PhD in Economics
  • Aug 15, 2024 Associate Professor of Econometrics (100%)
  • Aug 15, 2024 PhD Student (m/f/d) in health economics and/or development economics
  • Aug 15, 2024 Associate or Full Professorship in Microeconomics (100%)

Fill out the INOMICS Salary Survey & access our next annual job market review

INOMICS AI Tools

The INOMICS AI can generate an article summary or practice questions related to the content of this article. Try it now!

An error occured

Please try again later.

3 Practical questions, generated by our AI model

For more questions on economics study topics, with practice quizzes and detailed answer explanations, check out the INOMICS Study Guides.

Login to your account

Email Address

Forgot your password? Click here.

logo

  • Study Destination
  • News & Article

PhD Europe VS USA

PhD Europe VS USA

Embarking on a PhD journey is a significant milestone in one's academic career. Choosing the right destination for pursuing a doctorate is crucial and often leads to a dilemma for many aspiring researchers. Europe and the United States are popular choices for doctoral studies, offering world-class education and research opportunities. In this article, we will compare the experience of pursuing a PhD in Europe with that in the USA , shedding light on the various aspects that may influence your decision.

phd in us vs europe

Comparing PhD from Europe and PhD from the USA

Pursuing a doctoral degree requires considerable dedication and commitment. The choice of location can greatly impact your academic experience and prospects. Let's delve into the key factors when comparing a PhD from Europe and a PhD from the USA.

Academic Reputation and Funding Opportunities

Europe: a cradle of knowledge and diversity.

Europe boasts a rich academic heritage, with numerous renowned universities and research institutions. Institutions such as the University of Oxford, ETH Zurich, and Sorbonne University have long-standing traditions of excellence. The European research landscape is known for its diversity, enabling interdisciplinary collaborations and exposure to various perspectives.

USA: The Land of Cutting-Edge Research and Innovation

The United States is globally recognised as a scientific research and innovation leader. Top-tier universities like the Massachusetts Institute of Technology (MIT), Stanford University, and Harvard University consistently rank among the best in the world. The US offers abundant funding opportunities, thanks to federal grants and scholarships, making it an attractive destination for aspiring researchers.

2. Program Duration and Structure

Europe: structured programs with focus.

European PhD programs generally follow a structured format lasting three to four years. These programs emphasise specialisation in a specific research area, offering a well-defined curriculum and coursework. The structured approach ensures a focused research approach, often resulting in the timely completion of the degree.

USA: Flexible Programs Encouraging Exploration

PhD programs in the USA often have a more flexible structure, allowing students to explore different research areas and collaborate with multiple advisors. While the average duration of a US PhD program is around five to six years, the flexibility allows students to tailor their research according to their interests and evolve their thesis topic over time.

Research Funding and Financial Support

Europe: generous scholarships and grants.

In Europe, various funding opportunities are available for doctoral students. The European Research Council (ERC) and Marie Skłodowska-Curie Actions (MSCA) provide prestigious grants for research projects. Additionally, many European countries offer scholarships and stipends to support living expenses, making pursuing a PhD in Europe relatively affordable.

USA: Well-Funded Research and Teaching Assistantships

PhD students in the USA often receive financial support through research assistantships (RA) or teaching assistantships (TA). These positions offer a stipend, cover tuition fees, and provide valuable research or teaching experience. The competitive nature of funding in the US ensures that students receive substantial support throughout their doctoral journey.

Language of Instruction and Communication

Europe: multilingual environment.

Europe is linguistically diverse, with several countries offering PhD programs in different languages. While English is widely used in many institutions, non-English-speaking countries like Germany, France, and Spain may require proficiency in the local language. This multicultural environment can be enriching, offering opportunities to learn new languages and immerse oneself in different cultures.

USA: English as the Primary Language

English is the primary language of instruction and communication in most academic settings in the United States. International students are typically required to demonstrate proficiency in English through standardised tests such as TOEFL or IELTS . The advantage of studying in an English-speaking country is the ease of communication and access to a vast pool of resources in the language.

Research Culture and Collaboration

Europe: interdisciplinary collaborations.

European universities and research institutions foster a culture of collaboration and interdisciplinary research. Many institutions encourage students to collaborate with researchers from different disciplines, fostering innovation and creativity. This collaborative environment allows for a broader perspective and the opportunity to work on diverse projects.

USA: Extensive Research Networks

The United States has a well-established research ecosystem, with extensive networks and collaborations between universities, research centres, and industries. Students pursuing a PhD in the US can engage in cutting-edge research and benefit from the expertise of renowned scholars and industry professionals. These connections can lead to valuable networking opportunities and future career prospects.

Cost of Living and Scholarly Lifestyle

Europe: affordable living expenses.

The cost of living in Europe can vary significantly depending on the country and city. However, European cities generally offer a more affordable lifestyle than many American cities. This can be advantageous for students on a limited budget, as it allows them to focus more on their research without the burden of high living expenses.

USA: Higher Cost of Living

Living expenses in the United States, particularly in major cities like New York, Los Angeles, or San Francisco, can be considerably higher compared to many European cities. It is important for students to carefully consider the cost of living when planning their budget for a PhD in the US. However, the availability of financial support and scholarships in the US can mitigate these costs.

FAQs (Frequently Asked Questions)

1. is a phd from europe recognised in the usa.

Yes, a PhD from Europe is generally recognised in the USA. However, it is essential to have your degree evaluated by a credential evaluation service to determine its equivalency and ensure its recognition by potential employers or academic institutions in the US.

2. Are there any language requirements for a PhD in Europe?

The language requirements for a PhD in Europe vary depending on the country and institution. While many universities offer programs in English, some countries may require proficiency in the local language. You should check the specific language requirements of the universities you are interested in.

3. Can I switch from a European PhD program to a US program?

Switching from a European PhD program to a US one is possible but may involve additional requirements and evaluations. It is advisable to consult with the respective universities and understand their transfer policies and procedures.

4. Which option offers better research opportunities?

Both Europe and the USA offer excellent research opportunities. The choice ultimately depends on your research interests, the specific programs and institutions you are considering, and the available funding and resources in your chosen field of study.

5. Are there any differences in the application process for a PhD in Europe and the USA?

The application process for a PhD in Europe and the USA can vary. You may need to submit a detailed research proposal and your European application. At the same time, in the US, the focus is often on your academic background, recommendation letters, and statement of purpose. It is important to familiarise yourself with the specific requirements of each program and country.

6. Can I pursue a PhD in Europe or the USA as an international student?

Yes, both Europe and the USA welcome international students for PhD programs. However, it is important to research the specific visa requirements and any additional documentation or language proficiency tests that may be necessary for international students.

Choosing between pursuing a PhD in Europe or the USA is a significant decision that requires careful consideration of various factors. Both destinations offer world-class education, research opportunities, and diverse academic environments. Europe boasts a rich academic heritage, structured programs, and generous funding opportunities. On the other hand, the USA is renowned for its cutting-edge research, flexible programs, and extensive research networks.

When deciding, you must consider factors such as academic reputation, program duration and structure, research funding, language requirements, research culture, cost of living, and the overall academic and cultural experience you seek. Additionally, understanding the specific requirements and potential career prospects in your field of study is essential.

Ultimately, choosing between a PhD in Europe and a PhD in the USA depends on your preferences, research interests, and long-term goals. It is advisable to thoroughly research and reach out to universities, faculty members, and current students to gather more information and insights to help you make an informed decision.

Pursuing a PhD is a challenging yet rewarding journey that will shape your academic and professional future. By carefully considering the similarities and differences between a PhD in Europe and a PhD in the USA, you can embark on a path that aligns with your aspirations and maximises your potential.

Related Posts :

BSC Nursing in India

Find A Degree

18

Getting a PhD in the USA: A Complete Guide for International and Domestic Students

Phd program rankings.

  • Fully Funded PhDs in Education
  • Doctor of Nursing Education
  • Ph.D.: No Application Fees
  • No-GRE Online Ph.D. in Psychology
  • No-GRE Online Ph.D. Programs
  • Fast Online Doctoral (Ph.D. and Ed.D.)
  • The Most Affordable Online DBA
  • Doctorate in Public Policy/Administration
  • Doctor of ABA
  • Transitional Doctor of Physical Therapy (DPT)
  • Doctorate in Marketing
  • ALL Ph.D. Degree Program Rankings

Career Guides

  • Acupuncture and Oriental Medicine
  • Aerospace Engineering
  • Behavioral Health (D.B.H.)
  • Chemical Engineering (PhD CE)
  • Chemistry (D.Chem.)
  • Clinical Nutrition (D.C.N.)
  • Speech-Language Pathology (CScD)
  • Criminology (D.Crim.)
  • Economics (DEc)
  • Health Science (D.H.S./D.H.Sci)
  • Library Science (D.L.S.)
  • Molecular Biology (Phd Mol Biol)
  • Occupational Safety and Health (D.O.S.H.)
  • Physics (Ph.D. Physics)
  • ALL PhD Career Guides

Valuable Resources

  • Best Laptops for Ph.D. Students
  • Gift Ideas for Ph.D. Students
  • Burnout & Chronic Stress
  • The Key to Free Grad School
  • Ph.D. Guide for International and Domestic Students
  • Habits Of Highly Effective Leaders
  • Online Doctorate Reputation
  • Journals for Ph.D. Students
  • Earning a PhD
  • Write a Perfect Essay Like a PhD
  • Master’s Degree As a Bridge To Ph.D.
  • Self-Funding Your PhD
  • Importance of Accreditation
  • Online Ph.D. Support Groups
  • Getting Accepted to an Online Ph.D.
  • Common Fears of Ph.D. Students
  • Habits of Successful People
  • US Doctoral Degrees
  • ALL VALUABLE RESOURCES

Frequently Asked Questions

  • Why earn a Doctorate Degree?
  • What are the Ph.D. Admission Requirements?
  • How Much Does a Ph.D. Cost?
  • How many years will it take for me to achieve my doctorate degree online?
  • Do online doctorate degree programs require campus visits?
  • Ph.D. vs. Doctorate
  • ALL FREQUENTLY ASKED QUESTIONS
  • Highest-Paying Doctoral Degrees
  • Famous Ph.D. Theses In History
  • Struggles Only a Ph.D. Student Would Understand
  • Ph.D. Requiring Residencies
  • The World’s Richest Doctors
  • Academic Conferences
  • Most Popular PhD Degrees
  • ALL Ph.D. Highlights

If you’re looking for the right university to obtain your PhD at, then you’re probably already an expert in your area of interest and want to back that up with the right credentials. You may also be tempted by access to the world’s top universities’ research capabilities, which could allow you to conduct empirical studies of whatever it is that you’re interested in.

Regardless of whether you’re a math-oriented person looking to get a doctor’s degree in one of the STEM fields, or you’re more inclined towards social sciences, there is no better place for you to look for a satisfactory PhD program than the United States of America!

It’s home to some of the most prestigious universities in the world. With flexible curriculums, beautiful campus grounds, and some top-notch job opportunities, you’re sure to find what you’re looking for in the States.

There is a significant difference in the approach to PhD studies in the USA and the rest of the world. The PhD programs are much more structured and provide comprehensive, thorough training to complement your independent research.

One of the most challenging and troublesome parts of obtaining a PhD in the USA is the application process itself. There are plenty of things to take care of, and if you’re not stringent about it, you might find yourself failing to secure funding or worse yet, getting denied on your visa application.

Consider this page to be your go-to guide to the US PhD programs and opportunities. Here, you’ll find all the information you could possibly need regarding the PhD application process, the best schools to satisfy your research interests, as well as information regarding funding and tuition fees.

Enjoy these page jumps to navigate easier!

PhD in the USA vs. Anywhere Else

Public vs. private, graduate schools, the ivy league and other groups, online phd programs, usa university rankings 2021, new york city, san francisco, finding the right program and university: a checklist, structure of a phd program in the usa, application materials, admission requirements, finances and aid, the visa process, the bottom line.

The most fundamental difference between partaking in a PhD program in the United States and Europe is the structure of your studies. While the British and European universities tend to focus on the individual pursuit of your area of interest, schools in the States are more inclined towards helping you hone your skills and expertise. If you consider yourself more independent and don’t like too much oversight when conducting research, you may want to think twice before deciding to study in the USA.

American universities will allow you to apply for a PhD right after completing your undergraduate degree, whereas in European and British universities, a master’s degree is a requirement. So if the only accreditation you’ve got is a bachelor’s degree, but you still want to pursue a PhD, you’re left with no choice but to study in the USA.

In terms of workload, you’ll have much more to do at an American university. The entire duration of your program will be much longer than in the case of other schools, with about five to six years on average to complete the studies. In Europe, most PhD degrees can be obtained within three or four years.

On top of that, schools in the USA will actively encourage you to pursue research assistantships and other side activities that will not only contribute to your workload but could also serve as a means to generate additional income. While the positions of a research or teaching assistant are also available at European and British universities, these opportunities are not nearly as plentiful as in the case of American institutions.

Finally, there is one major difference in the application process. While students hoping to get into a university in the UK or Europe have to present their research project prior to getting into the school, it is a vital part of the decision process. On the other hand, in the US, you can apply to a particular department and submit your research proposal later on, after you’ve been accepted into the student body.

PhD in America 2021: Overview of Universities

The concentration of universities and other higher education establishments in the United States can give many prospective students quite a headache in the beginning. The US Department of Education lists 4,298 degree-granting educational institutions as of 2020. Not all of them can grant PhDs, but even after subtracting those out, you’ll still end up with a wide range of universities to pick from. To make it easier for you, we’ve categorized them so that you can narrow down your choice to the school profile that suits you best.

While the day-to-day campus life does not differ much, whether you’re in a public or a private school, the most important discrepancy is that regarding tuition fees. Public universities receive funding from governmental institutions, while private schools rely mostly on donations and other sources. This means that private institutions will charge higher tuition fees (on average) than public state universities.

If you’re from the USA, you should keep in mind that state (public) universities impose much lower fees on students originally from the same state as the school. If you’re not hellbent on moving out of your home state and exploring the country, you might want to consider looking at the local public options first, as you won’t have to chase after as much funding.

A graduate school is a specialized entity with the purpose of running its mother university’s graduate programs. There are various kinds of graduate schools — some of the largest and wealthiest universities in the USA might have a few of these, each one specializing in a particular subject.

It’s important to know what they are, since more likely than not, you’ll end up sending your PhD application over to a graduate school belonging to a certain university rather than the main institution itself. Keep this distinction in mind when applying — you don’t want to be enrolled in a bachelor’s degree program all over again!

When considering getting a PhD in the USA, you’ll come across one of the Ivy League schools sooner or later. The Ivy League is a group composed of the most prestigious higher education establishments in all of the United States. It includes schools like Harvard, Princeton, or Columbia University. The competition to get into one of these is fierce, and you might have to prove remarkable skill and aptitude in order to secure funding. As the elite of American universities, these institutions charge some of the world’s highest tuition fees.

Thankfully, your choice isn’t limited to the Ivy League. There are other university groups, such as the Public Ivy (comparable to Ivy League schools in terms of teaching quality with much lower fees) or the Association of American Universities (AAU).  Members of either of these groups offer quality education and research facilities at a fraction of the price of an Ivy League tuition.

Not everybody looking to obtain a PhD in the USA has the time and resources they can devote to the full-time pursuit of a degree. Whether it’s work or other responsibilities that are preventing you from enrolling in person, you should not give up on your ambitions. There are plenty of online PhD options in the USA for both domestic and international students. They usually come at a fraction of the cost of a regular, in-person degree, with funding options available as well.

You can find all sorts of PhD programs to pursue online, from computer science through management all the way to business administration. It’s also possible to study some of the more specialized subjects, such as behavioral analysis, which is quite convenient if you already have a masters degree in a more general area and would like to get a PhD in a certain niche.

There are plenty of official university rankings that pit all of the schools against each other with the aim of helping students find the most suitable program. Rankings such as the Times Higher Education Ranking or the TopUniversities Ranking are immensely helpful when it comes to comparing various schools and PhD curricula. Still, it’s important to avoid getting caught up in the comparison game too much.

There are thousands upon thousands of schools in the world, and the most prestigious, elite schools always take up the first 50 spots on these lists. This can lead some students to disregard some of the lower-ranked schools as not worthy of their time and money. Do not make that mistake. Aside from comparing universities using some of the rankings mentioned above, you should also check student satisfaction ratings and browse through lists of faculty members working at the department you’d like to apply to. These factors are equally as important as general rankings, and they might have a significant impact on your final decision.

Most Popular Student Cities

The USA is a huge country, and, like every large nation, its various regions are fundamentally different from each other. There are quite a few “student hotspots” across the fifty states. Here are four of the most popular ones. Each one is located in a completely different area of the country in order to give you the most complete overview of the US as a whole.

The Big Apple is probably the most popular student and tourist destination in the whole of the United States. It attracts dozens of thousands of prospective domestic and international students. It’s home to such prestigious institutions as the NYU, Columbia University, or the Juilliard School. NYC is a vibrant, multicultural metropolis — a great place to pursue higher education in performing arts or social sciences.

If you want to get a more gritty, day-to-day American reality, free of the distractions of the fairytale-like life in New York, you might want to give Chicago a shot. It isn’t as glamorous as NYC or San Francisco, which also means that the cost of living is a bit lower in this city. You’ll have a pick of some great schools, such as the University of Chicago or the Northeastern University of Illinois, just to name a few.

San Francisco has traditionally been at the forefront of social justice in the USA. As such, it is one of the most inclusive and friendly cities for students from all kinds of different backgrounds. Unfortunately, the same cannot be said about the cost of living in San Francisco or all of California, for that matter. Since the city’s close proximity to Silicon Valley, it makes for a great place for students pursuing a PhD in the STEM fields. You’ll have the opportunity to land an internship or a full-time position at one of the tech giants located there. The competition is fierce, though, so you’ll have to be at your very best to stand a chance!

You might be slightly baffled by seeing a Texas city on a list of the most student-friendly places, but there was simply no way for us to exclude Houston from this list, especially if you’re looking for a place to get a PhD in USA. Houston is home to Rice University, a school with a strong focus on comprehensive research. There is also the University of Houston or the Texas Southern University, both of which are strong, household names with rich histories.

The Sunbelt Capital is the perfect place to meet some great, like-minded people and focus on your research, far away from the hustle and bustle of New York or San Francisco, not to mention the complete lack of annoying travelers and tourist-trap restaurants!

Choosing the right school to obtain a PhD is a tough task. Once you’ve narrowed down your options a little by taking a look at the rankings and finding a city to spend the next six years of your life in, you need to take a more detailed look at the universities and the programs they have on offer. If you’re having trouble evaluating all of the information, help yourself by using the checklist below!

  • Research facilities . Do they suit your needs? Are you going to be able to conduct all of the empirical and theoretical research you need to complete your PhD dissertation?
  • Faculty members . Take a good, long look at all of the professors who work at each school. Try and identify those whose work interests you the most — those people will be immensely helpful throughout your PhD program.
  • Funding opportunities . Look into all of the scholarships, grants, research, and teaching assistantships available at each school to see where you’re most likely to secure funding.
  • Job placement rates . In the end, the likelihood of you getting a job is entirely up to you and your own skills and experience, but the university you’ve graduated from can influence these characteristics in more than one way. Checking up on how many former students of the department you’re interested in have achieved professional success can be a good way of evaluating the actual quality of education you’ll get at each particular institution.
  • Extra-curriculars . Whether it is on-campus activities, groups, or teams, or activities outside of the school grounds, you should make sure that there is something you can do in your free time in the vicinity of your chosen university. Four to six years is a very long time, and you’re not going to spend all of it studying.

The initial stages of a PhD in USA are very similar to taught masters degree programs. You might even end up in some courses with masters students in the beginning! The taught classes and modules are divided into two groups: core classes and elective courses . The completion of core subjects is obligatory if you want to pass the year, while elective courses are optional, but bear in mind that you will need to pass some of them in order to satisfy the program requirements.

Once you’re done with all of your classes, you’ll have to pass a dissertation qualifying exam , which is a comprehensive examination that will test your knowledge and evaluate whether or not you’re qualified to carry out your own research.

After the exam, you’ll have to go through the lengthy and difficult process of conducting research and writing your dissertation. This stage of a PhD study consists of choosing your research topic and submitting a dissertation prospectus (research proposal). This is an essay outlining the entire project, your methodology, and the intended outcomes. Afterward, you’ll be assigned a group of advisors (a.k.a. “committee of supervisors”) who will provide you with assistance and evaluate your work as you go along.

As for the grading and assessment of your work during the US PhD program, you will be assessed based on the following:

  • Coursework – essays and examinations from all of your core and elective courses,
  • Examinations – a comprehensive exam that meant to assess whether you’re ready to begin conducting research or not,
  • Dissertation prospectus – the outline of your intended research and its oral defense,
  • Dissertation defense   –  the culmination of your PhD pursuit — the presentation and oral defense of your dissertation.

Applying for a PhD in the USA: What to Expect?

Once you start applying to your chosen schools, it is important to keep calm and have an alternative course of action in mind in case things don’t go the way you planned. Admissions to American schools are amongst some of the most competitive globally, so there is a high likelihood of failure at every stage of the process.

Even students with impeccable accreditation and outstanding letters of recommendation get rejected, which is why it is so important to be mentally prepared for every outcome.

As for the practical side of things, everything you’ll need to submit is listed below.

It’s quite likely that some universities will expect you to submit some extra materials with your PhD application, but you’re expected to have the following at the ready regardless of where you’re applying:

  • academic transcripts,
  • personal statement,
  • entry test scores,
  • CV (resume),
  • letters of recommendation,
  • research statement,
  • writing samples.

You already know that a master’s degree isn’t a requirement to pursue a PhD in USA. There are, however, other criteria that schools will use to evaluate whether or not you’re a suitable candidate. This includes a Grade Point Average (GPA) based on the academic transcripts you’ve provided, your Graduate Records Exam (GRE) results, as well as widely recognized English proficiency test (ex. IELTS or TOEFL) if you come from a non-English speaking country. 

After you’ve successfully satisfied the admission requirements presented above, some schools might invite you for a format interview, after which they will come to a final decision. Keep in mind that not all schools hold interviews, and many of them will accept or deny your application based only upon the submitted materials.

Tuition payments for a PhD study in the United States are incredibly high, with dozens of thousands of dollars per year being the standard nationwide. According to the American National Center for Education Statistics, the average yearly fee at private universities was as high as $44,000. Public (state) universities charge much less than that, although it is still a hefty fee at around $13,000 per year for in-state students.

Those coming from another state or abroad should expect a much higher payment, albeit still lower than what they’d need to pay at one of the private establishments.

You should plan your finances ahead of your PhD application so that you don’t end up with crippling debt at the end of your studies (unless you’re absolutely certain that you’re able to pay it off). Whether it’s through various assistantships at the school, funding programs, or scholarships, you should not have to go into your PhD studies worrying about how you’re going to pay for them.

Information for International Students

Incoming international students need to face additional screening and evaluation in order to get admitted to their chosen university. This is mostly due to the lengthy visa process , but you should also have some time set aside to figure out your living arrangements and travel itinerary.

Once you’re accepted for a PhD at a university approved by the Student Exchange and Visitor Programme, the visa process will be fairly straightforward, albeit lengthy, and quite unpleasant. Here are the main steps that students wishing to enroll in a PhD program at an American university need to go through:

  • Paying the $200 SEVIS registration fee . The Student Exchange Visitor Information System charges a pretty hefty fee for registering you within their ranks. Unfortunately, without this payment, your university won’t be able to provide you with the right visa application form (the I-20).
  • Filling out the online application . This will require you to fill out another form, as well as upload a current picture of yourself. You’ll also have to pay a $160 application fee.
  • Schedule and attend a visa interview . The interview will take place in the US Embassy in your home country, and it’s not as scary as it sounds. Just make sure to bring all of the required documents, and you’ll be good to go!

If you want to avoid going through all that trouble just to be able to get a PhD in the USA, remember that you can also complete an online program with a school located in the States. These degrees are just as valid as those obtained in the traditional manner, with the added benefit of students completing all the coursework at their own pace, should their schedule not allow them to enroll in a full-time PhD program.

Getting a PhD in USA is a major aspiration of many students all over the world. Such a degree opens up many career paths, not to mention the ability to teach at universities! A PhD is particularly helpful if you want to land a well-paying job in the USA as a foreigner. It is much easier to get a work visa with such accreditation, especially if you’ve received your PhD at an American university.

Not only does a PhD provide you with many opportunities that would otherwise have been unavailable to you, but it also immensely contributes to your personal growth. Becoming a true expert in your area of interest is incredibly fulfilling, arguably more so than the career prospects that come with a PhD degree.

  • The University of Melbourne

Why study at Technical University of Munich

  • France Extends Post-Study Visa to 5 Years for Indian Students
  •     Gedik University ,Istanbul
  • Why study at California Institute of Technology

Kourses Abroad

PhD programmes Comparison: the US Vs Europe (Part 1)

Are you considering pursuing a PhD abroad? Before applying, you should be aware of certain significant distinctions between PhD programmes offered in Europe and America. By reading on, you will discover which programme is best for you.

Qualifications

In Europe, obtaining a Master’s degree is frequently a prerequisite for pursuing a PhD. In the US, a lot of PhD programmes accept candidates with only a Bachelor’s degree. Following several years of study and the successful completion of specific tests, students typically receive a Master’s degree as part of their PhD programme. This does not imply that all PhD candidates in American programmes have come directly from undergrad. Many still opt to complete a Master’s degree before going for a PhD. Students with a Master’s degree may not need to take as many courses in some programmes as those with only a Bachelor’s degree, but this isn’t always the case.

Degree Duration

PhD programmes in Europe are less time-consuming than those in the US. For instance, the duration of a PhD in France, Norway, the UK, and Germany is three years. A three-to-four-year PhD is typical throughout Europe. In contrast, the US takes six years on average to complete a degree, with many PhDs in the humanities needing seven or eight years to complete.

Thesis Subject

The thesis subject and advisor for PhD applicants in Europe must be determined at the time of application. Students apply for particular vacant PhD positions that are frequently associated with a professor’s research. They must produce a research proposal for this project as a part of their application. Applicants must still submit a research proposal and are urged to get in touch with potential supervisors before applying. It is also feasible to apply to a department rather than a single position (in the UK, for example). Instead of applying to a particular PhD project, individuals in the US apply to a department’s PhD programme. Students do not choose their thesis topic until their second or third year, even though they must outline their research interests and suggest suitable supervisors in their applications. In reality, before choosing their supervisor and dissertation research, first-year students in many science and engineering programmes move between various labs.

Teaching Requirement

Although teaching is not often required in many nations, PhD candidates occasionally have the chance to do so in Europe. In the US, PhD candidates are frequently expected to instruct undergrads, frequently as teaching assistants in a big lecture class. Twenty to thirty students are led in smaller tutorials by a teaching assistant, who also grades their tests and homework. For two to three years, the majority of PhD candidates will TA one course per semester. Graduate students in several American PhD programmes must take pedagogy courses as a requirement.

  • How to Avoid Common Scholarship Application Errors 
  • PhD programmes Comparison: the US Vs Europe (Part 2)

You May Also Like

Burj Al Arab, Dubai

What draws international students to the Middle East?

Technical University of Munich campus

How to Get Australian Student Visa?

Leave a reply cancel reply.

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Save my name, email, and website in this browser for the next time I comment.

WhatsApp us

Stack Exchange Network

Stack Exchange network consists of 183 Q&A communities including Stack Overflow , the largest, most trusted online community for developers to learn, share their knowledge, and build their careers.

Q&A for work

Connect and share knowledge within a single location that is structured and easy to search.

Why are US PhDs different from European PhDs?

So apparently I heard from here , here and here about the differences in PhDs in the US and in Europe.

To sum up, it takes longer, on average, in the US than in Europe to finish a PhD since US PhD programs require less and have more coursework compared to Eur PhD programs.

Why is that so?

I tried looking it up but seemed to be getting the stuff above, nothing really explaining why that is so.

  • graduate-school
  • united-states

Community's user avatar

  • 10 Like everything else: history, habits, 'culture', etc. –  Cape Code Commented Apr 10, 2015 at 12:02
  • 17 Can you clarify what you mean by "require less and have more coursework"? –  ruakh Commented Apr 10, 2015 at 18:01
  • 13 It's actually amazing that something as complex as "a PhD" exists around the world and is similar enough everywhere that it makes sense to use one term for all the varieties. –  RemcoGerlich Commented Apr 10, 2015 at 18:28
  • 8 Why does milk in Canada come in bags but in USA it comes in jugs? –  Superbest Commented Apr 10, 2015 at 23:10
  • 9 @Superbest: Wait, what... bags ?! –  Lightness Races in Orbit Commented Apr 12, 2015 at 15:37

7 Answers 7

First, let me start off with a counter-question:

Why would you expect them to be exactly the same?

Different regions have historically different educational systems on all levels, starting from Kindergarten. Why would you expect specifically the PhD degree to have a completely uniform definition everywhere in the world? Of course there are nowadays activities to make degrees (incl. PhDs) more comparable worldwide, but these things take time. As politicians in Europe have learned as part of the so-called Bologna process, you can't just top-down decide that from now on, we are using the US system .

Of course, there are sometimes reasonable arguments for differences in system. For instance, you concluded:

it takes longer, on average, in the US than in Europe to finish a PhD since US PhD programs require less and have more coursework compared to Eur PhD programs.

In the US, a bachelor's degree is required for starting a PhD. In Europe, almost universally, you need a master or one of the older five-year diploma studies. So we in Europe expect students to hit the ground running basically from day 1 in their PhD. On the other hand, we don't require them to do much, or any, course work because they did all of that as part of the previous studies. Of course, if you then look only at the pure time spend in what is called the PhD studies, you end up with a shorter time in Europe.

Now you can of course go deeper down the rabbit hole and ask why European universities expect PhD students to have a master's degree first. The reason for that is mostly historical - around here, we often didn't even have Bachelor's degrees until the above-mentioned Bolognia process. What happened as part of this process was that decision makers ended up deciding that pretty much the first three years of the old diploma studies became "the bachelor" while the remaining two years became "the master". Of course, this reasoning led to the public opinion of somebody with "only" a bachelor's degree as a glorified college dropout. The universities implicitly also shared this notion, as there were never substantial motions to admit bachelor degree holders to PhD programmes in most universities. Slowly, the bachelor programmes are getting more profile as something better than just the first 3/5 of an actual degree programme, and consequently their public image also improves. Universities are nowadays also taking first tender steps towards making it easier for bachelor degree holders to start a PhD - however, so far, this is mostly targeted at making it easier for international students to enroll.

Important concluding remark: I am aware that a lot of the above contained pretty sweeping generalizations, which do not hold true everywhere. Specifically, Great Britain and Ireland already historically used a different system. However, I wanted to answer with something a bit more substantial than "systems are different everywhere".

earthling's user avatar

  • 15 around here, we often didn't even have Bachelor's degrees until the above-mentioned Bolognia process very true. Also, PhD itself is 'new' in many European countries, it used to be called a doctorate. –  Cape Code Commented Apr 10, 2015 at 12:36
  • 6 @CapeCode Yup. Still the case in Austria, as far as I know. Funnily, just a car drive away in Italy, "Dottore" means something entirely different. –  xLeitix Commented Apr 10, 2015 at 13:09
  • 7 @xLeitix: in fact in Italy, the title Dottore refers to one who has a bachelor degree, but also to a physician. The title for one who has a master degree is Dottore magistrale . The PhD was born in Italy just thirty years ago and the corresponding title is Dottore di ricerca . So, almost anybody who has some kind of degree can be called doctor (no one actually uses the qualifiers). –  Massimo Ortolano Commented Apr 10, 2015 at 15:27
  • 7 @CapeCode It is still not called PhD in many European countries (if not most). –  user9646 Commented Apr 10, 2015 at 18:04
  • 4 @Mehrdad They are not. The name "PhD" is not officially used in many European countries, and if it is, it is often only used since Bolognia. –  xLeitix Commented Apr 11, 2015 at 7:24

I can talk about PhDs in the UK, I have less knowledge of the rest of Europe, but I know that it is not similar to the US.

In the UK, you specialize early in a subject, and your education is therefore narrow and deep. In the US, you specialize later, and your education is therefore wide and not so deep. It's changed a little (but only a little) since I was in school, but at age 13, I dropped all but 5 subjects plus math(s) and English. I chose the three sciences (chemistry, biology, physics), geometrical and engineering drawing, and French. If you chose not to take any science at age 13, you were not going to be studying any science at university (I think this is changed, so you are required to take at least some sciene). Hence I have studied no humanities since I was 13. At age 16, you reduced again to three subjects - you are interested in science, people typically studied physics, chemistry, biology, or perhaps swapped the biology for maths. When I teach psychology undergraduates, health science undergraduates, or health professionals who are taking postgraduate courses, they will typically have done no math(s) since the age of 16. (This is a challenge, as I teach them statistics. If they knew anything about algebra, they've forgotten most of it. They will deny ever having been taught calculus [and that's true, they probably have never studied it]).

At 16, I chose biology, psychology and environmental science. (Env Sci is, or was, essentially applied chemistry and biology, with a bit of geography).

In the UK, you go to university to study a subject, and that is what you study. There is no concept of picking a major. If you want to change your major, you usually start again. (In my first year, I studied two subsidiary subjects for 50% of the time, after the first year, I did nothing except psychology courses.

When I graduated at age 21, I had a degree in psychology, and I'd been studying psychology for 5 years (and psychology had made up almost 2/3rds of what I'd studied from age 16).

The PhD has also changed, but in the UK at the time, the purpose of the PhD was to write a dissertation. That was the only requirement. In the US, there is the idea of PhD-ABD - all but dissertation. In the UK, this would make no sense, there is no requirement for a PhD except for the dissertation. You start, and on day 1 you work on your dissertaion. On day N (where N is quite a large number) you submit your dissertation, and you're finished. This is changing, or has changed so that there is a coursework requirement for a PhD; but in the US people talk about taking courses in departments outside their PhD subject. This is very rare in the UK - you take courses offered by your department, and you take the courses you have to take, no more. British PhD dissertations are considerably longer and more substantial than American PhD dissertations.

In comparison to an American student, a UK graduate in (say) psychology seems to know more psychology. But they know a lot less other stuff. In the US, it seems (to me) to be common to do a master's degree (or even a PhD) in a subject that you did not major in at undergraduate. For example, I've known people with a degree in economics or sociology who take a master's degree in statistics. This would be very rare in the UK, you would simply be too far behind everyone else on the course. (Many years ago, I applied for a master's course in applied statistics (an early online course) - I'd published papers on statistical methods in psychology, and had a PhD on statistical methods in psychology; I was rejected because my background was unsuitable.)

Jeremy Miles's user avatar

  • But why exactly? "In the UK, you specialize early in a subject, and your education is therefore narrow and deep. In the US, you specialize later, and your education is therefore wide and not so deep." –  BCLC Commented May 19, 2015 at 18:41
  • Hmmm... I've never heard of a reason. I guess if you're designing a system you can choose narrow and deep or wide and shallow. I'm not sure why one country went one way, and the other went the other. –  Jeremy Miles Commented May 21, 2015 at 18:18
  • 1 @xLeitix actually answered :P –  BCLC Commented May 22, 2015 at 8:08
  • Why do you think its not similar in other parts of Europe? Here in Germany, for example, it is pretty much the same... –  adjan Commented Oct 29, 2018 at 13:56
  • @Adrian - same as in the US or the same as UK? I've edited my answer to clarify. –  Jeremy Miles Commented Oct 31, 2018 at 15:48

I think the goal is to get people to do the work of (approximately) 4 years undergrad, plus 2 years Master's work, plus 3-5 years of doctoral-level research. You can either lump that into 3 explicit degrees, or you can lump the latter two into one degree and just do a Bachelor's and a PhD. The overall amount of work is not that different. Not all people will get this equivalent level of training, but lots more programs have this level of required work than the simple US/EU divide would suggest.

Some folks (many? most?) in the US that enter a PhD program directly after their Bachelor's degree are eligible to pick up a Master's degree along the way based on completing the required coursework for the PhD. Some just don't bother to fill out the paperwork. I didn't. In the end, it doesn't really matter. Additionally, if you enter a US PhD program with an appropriate Master's degree, you can almost always short-circuit the initial coursework requirements and go straight to research. I think it's probably less common to do this because it requires 3 college applications and maybe more moving around than does staying at your first graduate institution, but some people do it.

Bill Barth's user avatar

  • 2 Except in the UK it is often 3 years of undergrad follow directly by a 3 year PhD. I think it is probably better to describe it as foundational coursework followed by 1-2 years of advance coursework. –  StrongBad Commented Apr 10, 2015 at 12:20
  • 1 @StrongBad, yeah, though I gather the UK is a bit of an outlier in this regard. –  Bill Barth Commented Apr 10, 2015 at 13:18
  • Typo, or what : Some just don't bother to fill out the paperwork because. I didn't ?? Funnily, seems to suggest - they don't, because you didn't. #Trendsetter (otherwise, +1) –  299792458 Commented Apr 10, 2015 at 17:24
  • @TheDarkSide, sorry I was going to give a reason, but then I couldn't remember why I didn't bother. So I've removed the extra word. –  Bill Barth Commented Apr 10, 2015 at 17:42
  • 2 @StrongBad yes, and the UK pattern (in the sciences) has now become 3 years to a bachelor's or 4 to an MSci (which isn't the same as a (postgraduate) MSc), and that has now become the usual PhD-entry degree. ...Except in Scotland, where the university-entry exams can be completed at 17, and the degree is generally 4 years, or now 5 for an MSci. Thus the differences go all the way back to school exams. (This also means that it's unusual, but not freakishly so, for someone to be at university in Scotland at age 16). –  Norman Gray Commented Apr 10, 2015 at 18:56

The idea that European PhDs are uniform is misleading. Similar, there is no single US PhD. The differences in PhD programs, stem from differences that develop during primary and secondary education. For example, in the UK students begin specialising during their "A levels" and the undergraduate degree is a highly specialized 3 year degree. In the US, secondary education and the undergraduate degree include more breadth.

The teaching responsibilities in the US and UK are also different, with there being less off topic advanced level teaching in the UK. This means that post graduate course work, is to an extent less important, since you will not likely be teaching that material. For example, a CS researcher teaching in a small US EECS department might be required to teach undergraduate signal processing, but this would almost never happen in the UK. Having taken a graduate level class is really helpful for teaching undergraduate level classes.

Finally, there are cultural differences. In the UK, there is more pressure to get a job. In the UK, many people opt to skip a research intensive post doc and instead go directly into teaching intensive positions with the hope of switching tracks later. The funding models are different also

TL;DR They are different, because they are different.

StrongBad's user avatar

  • Thanks StrongBad. "Having taken a graduate level class is really helpful for teaching undergraduate level classes." Why? –  BCLC Commented Jul 29, 2015 at 16:40
  • 1 @JackBauer this might be better as a new question, but graduate level classes cover the material in so much more depth that they usually prepare you for any questions undergraduates might ask and give you options about how to steer the class. –  StrongBad Commented Jul 30, 2015 at 20:32
  • I'm sorry. I have no idea why I asked that. No one out of undergraduate studies can just teach junior or senior undergraduate classes without taking a master's degree, in general. –  BCLC Commented Jul 31, 2015 at 18:22

There is a lot of diversity in American universities and a lot more in Europe. I have studied in four European countries and all of them had different PhD award requirement and average PhD duration, course work requirements, etc. A sweeping generalization would be that European universities require a master's degree, and PhD on average takes three years and in the US you require a certain number of credits and a bachelor's degree.

In reality, there is a lot of variability. Some American universities do require a master's degree before a PhD - e.g. doctoral programmes in engineering at UIUC . But many others admit you to begin a PhD and then expect you to either get a master's degree along the way fulfilling course credits or allow you to transfer those credits to PhD directly.

Interesting fun fact - several American and European universities have admitted anyone who passes the entrance exam to a doctoral programme - even if they didn't have a bachelor's degree. What they expect, to award a PhD, is just contribution to the field and proof of competence as a researcher. But now we have institutions that enforce credit systems, quality control and so on, so there are these hard requirements at some level subject to many things imposed by institutions based on country, credit system, university, discipline, department, PhD award committee and even perhaps professors.

These limitations now exist because there are way too many institutions and universities now, and I won't be surprised if there is someone out there who is doing a PhD in this very subject. If you find them, let me know. :D

Peter Mortensen's user avatar

  • But why exactly? "A sweeping generalization would be that European universities require a master's degree, and PhD on average takes three years and in the US you require a certain number of credits and a bachelor's degree." –  BCLC Commented May 19, 2015 at 18:41
  • 1 Read this - en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bologna_Process –  Solomon Vimal Commented May 20, 2015 at 19:00
  • @xLeitix actually answered that :P –  BCLC Commented May 22, 2015 at 8:08

European countries agreed a few years ago on having all similar official durations for PhDs (3-4 years). See https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bologna_Process .

In all european countries starting a PhD requires having completed 5 years of study (european master degree), while in US it is in theory possible to start a PhD after 3-4 years of study.

TAship is less common and far less stringent in most european countries than in US.

Ant's user avatar

" Habilitation "

In Germany and many other European countries, historically, a PhD was not enough to get a professorship (whereas in the US a PhD is required for associate-professor positions, I think).

In many fields, PhDs had to apply to the tenure committe, and then were allowed to write and submit a " Habilitation " paper or internal report. After acceptance, then you could apply for a professorship, and be tenured.

So, historically, often:

(Professorship qualification phase duration in Europe) = PhD phase + Habilitation phase

This requirement has been "reformed away" since the 2000s, and often been replaced by "junior professorships" (multiyear fixed-term contracts).

Local traditions and requirements with respect to "Habilitation" strongly differ. in some fields this still exists; and at some universities, it has been "reformed away" even earlier.

For "University of Applied Sciences" (Fachhochschulen - less prestigious but still pretty good universities), there was no such requirement.

knb's user avatar

  • So, the fact that before getting a PhD wasn't enough to get a professorship meant that PhDs did not take that long, and it remains similar to this day? –  BCLC Commented Apr 16, 2015 at 17:42
  • 1 Over the decades, PhDs durations have become longer. Professors in the drastic-reform periods (after WW2, and 1970s) needed less time, e.g. Bachelor directly to PhD was more common. Since the 1990s, a PhD in STEM Fields is scheduled to take 3 years (in most cases, funding is provided for 3 years), but can take longer. In Law planned duration is less, in medical schools it is less (6 Months - several years). Teaching load is less. –  knb Commented Apr 17, 2015 at 9:29

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for browse other questions tagged phd graduate-school united-states europe ..

  • Featured on Meta
  • Bringing clarity to status tag usage on meta sites
  • We've made changes to our Terms of Service & Privacy Policy - July 2024
  • Announcing a change to the data-dump process

Hot Network Questions

  • View coordinates of PDF on MacOS - pinlabel needed
  • Unstable output C++: running the same thing twice gives different output
  • Would a manned Mars landing be possible with Apollo-era technology?
  • Find a basis for this set of vectors
  • Tiling a rectangle with one-sided P-pentominoes
  • How can I cross an overpass in "Street View" without being dropped to the roadway below?
  • How can sound travel as a transverse wave?
  • Birthday of combinatorial game product
  • Did Newton predict the deflection of light by gravity?
  • Large scale structure/Single galaxy simulation on GPU
  • Why is Excel not counting time with COUNTIF?
  • What is the meaning of 'in the note'?
  • apply all shape keys to selected objects except certain shape keys
  • Why don't programming languages or IDEs support attaching descriptive metadata to variables?
  • Formatting Column Headers with siunitx
  • The word "let" as in "without let or hindrance"
  • What was I thinking when I drew this diagram?
  • Why are the perfect fifth and fourth called "perfect" in 12-ET when they differ by approximately 2 cents from just intonation?
  • Expected returns vs annualized returns
  • Can you cast a non-cantrip spell using your action, and make a bonus action melee spell attack on the same turn?
  • Automatically closing a water valve after a few minutes
  • Every time I see her, she said you've not been doing me again
  • Can I continue using technology after it is patented
  • Why do individuals with revoked master’s/PhD degrees due to plagiarism or misconduct not return to retake them?

phd in us vs europe

FactCheck.org

Attacks on Walz’s Military Record

By Robert Farley , D'Angelo Gore and Eugene Kiely

Posted on August 8, 2024 | Updated on August 12, 2024 | Corrected on August 9, 2024

Este artículo estará disponible en español en El Tiempo Latino .

In introducing her pick for vice presidential running mate, Kamala Harris has prominently touted Tim Walz’s 24 years of service in the Army National Guard. Now, however, GOP vice presidential nominee JD Vance and the Trump campaign are attacking Walz on his military record, accusing the Minnesota governor of “stolen valor.”

We’ll sort through the facts surrounding the three main attacks on Walz’s military record and let readers decide their merit. The claims include:

  • Vance claimed that Walz “dropped out” of the National Guard when he learned his battalion was slated to be deployed to Iraq. Walz retired to focus on a run for Congress two months before his unit got official word of impending deployment, though the possibility had been rumored for months.
  • Vance also accused Walz of having once claimed to have served in combat, when he did not. While advocating a ban on assault-style weapons, Walz said, “We can make sure that those weapons of war that I carried in war, is the only place where those weapons are at.” Update, Aug. 12: The Harris campaign says that Walz “misspoke.”
  • The Republican National Committee has criticized Walz for misrepresenting his military rank in campaign materials. The Harris campaign website salutes Walz for “rising to the rank of Command Sergeant Major.” Walz did rise to that rank, but he retired as a master sergeant because he had not completed the requirements of a command sergeant major.

A native of West Point, Nebraska, Walz joined the Nebraska Army National Guard in April 1981, two days after his 17th birthday. When Walz and his wife moved to Minnesota in 1996, he transferred to the Minnesota National Guard, where he served in 1st Battalion, 125th Field Artillery.

“While serving in Minnesota, his military occupational specialties were 13B – a cannon crewmember who operates and maintains cannons and 13Z -field artillery senior sergeant,” according to a statement released by Army Lt. Col. Kristen Augé, the Minnesota National Guard’s state public affairs officer.

According to MPR News , Walz suffered some hearing impairment related to exposure to cannon booms during training over the years, and he underwent some corrective surgery to address it.

On Aug. 3, 2003, “Walz mobilized with the Minnesota National Guard’s 1st Battalion, 125th Field Artillery … to support Operation Enduring Freedom. The battalion supported security missions at various locations in Europe and Turkey. Governor Walz was stationed at Vicenza, Italy, during his deployment,” Augé stated. The deployment lasted about eight months.

“For 24 years I proudly wore the uniform of this nation,” Walz said at a rally in Philadelphia where he was announced as Harris’ running mate on Aug. 6. “The National Guard gave me purpose. It gave me the strength of a shared commitment to something greater than ourselves.”

Walz’s Retirement from the National Guard

In recent years, however, several of his fellow guard members have taken issue with the timing of Walz’s retirement from the National Guard in May 2005, claiming he left to avoid a deployment to Iraq.

phd in us vs europe

Vance, who served a four-year active duty enlistment in the Marine Corps as a combat correspondent, serving in Iraq for six months in 2005, advanced that argument at a campaign event on Aug. 7.

“When the United States of America asked me to go to Iraq to serve my country, I did it,” Vance said. “When Tim Walz was asked by his country to go to Iraq, you know what he did? He dropped out of the Army and allowed his unit to go without him, a fact that he’s been criticized for aggressively by a lot of the people that he served with. I think it’s shameful to prepare your unit to go to Iraq, to make a promise that you’re going to follow through and then to drop out right before you actually have to go.”

In early 2005, Walz, then a high school geography teacher and football coach at Mankato West High School, decided to run for public office. In a 2009 interview Walz provided as part of the Library of Congress’ veterans oral history project, Walz said he made the decision to retire from the National Guard to “focus full time” on a run for the U.S. House of Representatives for Minnesota’s 1st Congressional District (which he ultimately won in 2006). Walz said he was “really concerned” about trying to seek public office and serve in the National Guard at the same time without running afoul of the Hatch Act , which limits political speech by federal employees, including members of the National Guard.

Federal Election Commission records show that Walz filed to run for Congress on Feb. 10, 2005.

On March 20, 2005, Walz’s campaign put out a press release titled “Walz Still Planning to Run for Congress Despite Possible Call to Duty in Iraq.”

Three days prior, the release said, “the National Guard Public Affairs Office announced a possible partial mobilization of roughly 2,000 troops from the Minnesota National Guard. … The announcement from the National Guard PAO specified that all or a portion of Walz’s battalion could be mobilized to serve in Iraq within the next two years.”

According to the release, “When asked about his possible deployment to Iraq Walz said, ‘I do not yet know if my artillery unit will be part of this mobilization and I am unable to comment further on specifics of the deployment.’ Although his tour of duty in Iraq might coincide with his campaign for Minnesota’s 1st Congressional seat, Walz is determined to stay in the race. ‘As Command Sergeant Major I have a responsibility not only to ready my battalion for Iraq, but also to serve if called on. I am dedicated to serving my country to the best of my ability, whether that is in Washington DC or in Iraq.'”

On March 23, 2005, the Pipestone County Star reported, “Detachments of the Minnesota National Guard have been ‘alerted’ of possible deployment to Iraq in mid-to-late 2006.”

“Major Kevin Olson of the Minnesota National Guard said a brigade-sized contingent of soldiers could be expected to be called to Iraq, but he was not, at this time, aware of which batteries would be called,” the story said. “All soldiers in the First Brigade combat team of the 34th Division, Minnesota National Guard, could be eligible for call-up. ‘We don’t know yet what the force is like’ he said. ‘It’s too early to speculate, if the (soldiers) do go.’

“He added: ‘We will have a major announcement if and when the alert order moves ahead.’”

ABC News spoke to Joseph Eustice, a retired command sergeant major who served with Walz, and he told the news organization this week that “he remembers Walz struggling with the timing of wanting to serve as a lawmaker but also avoiding asking for a deferment so he could do so.”

“He had a window of time,” Eustice told ABC News. “He had to decide. And in his deciding, we were not on notice to be deployed. There were rumors. There were lots of rumors, and we didn’t know where we were going until it was later that, early summer, I believe.”

Al Bonnifield, who served under Walz, also recalled Walz agonizing over the decision.

“It was a very long conversation behind closed doors,” Bonnifield told the Washington Post this week. “He was trying to decide where he could do better for soldiers, for veterans, for the country. He weighed that for a long time.”

In 2018, Bonnifield told MPR News that Walz worried in early 2005, “Would the soldier look down on him because he didn’t go with us? Would the common soldier say, ‘Hey, he didn’t go with us, he’s trying to skip out on a deployment?’ And he wasn’t. He talked with us for quite a while on that subject. He weighed that decision to run for Congress very heavy. He loved the military, he loved the guard, he loved the soldiers he worked with.”

But not all of Walz’s fellow Guard members felt that way.

In a paid letter to the West Central Tribune in Minnesota in November 2018, Thomas Behrends and Paul Herr — both retired command sergeants major in the Minnesota National Guard — wrote, “On May 16th, 2005 he [Walz] quit, leaving the 1-125th Field Artillery Battalion and its Soldiers hanging; without its senior Non-Commissioned Officer, as the battalion prepared for war. His excuse to other leaders was that he needed to retire in order to run for congress. Which is false, according to a Department of Defense Directive, he could have run and requested permission from the Secretary of Defense before entering active duty; as many reservists have.”

“For Tim Walz to abandon his fellow soldiers and quit when they needed experienced leadership most is disheartening,” they wrote. “When the nation called, he quit.”

Walz retired on May 16, 2005. Walz’s brigade received alert orders for mobilization on July 14, 2005, according to the National Guard and MPR News . The official mobilization report came the following month, and the unit mobilized and trained through the fall. It was finally deployed to Iraq in the spring of 2006.

The unit was originally scheduled to return in February 2007, but its tour was extended four months as part of President George W. Bush’s “surge” strategy , the National Guard reported. In all, the soldiers were mobilized for 22 months.

Responding to Vance’s claim that Walz retired to avoid deploying to Iraq, the Harris-Walz campaign released a statement saying, “After 24 years of military service, Governor Walz retired in 2005 and ran for Congress, where he was a tireless advocate for our men and women in uniform – and as Vice President of the United States he will continue to be a relentless champion for our veterans and military families.”

Walz on Carrying a Weapon ‘in War’

Vance also called Walz “dishonest” for a claim that Walz made in 2018 while speaking to a group about gun control.

“He made this interesting comment that the Kamala Harris campaign put out there,” Vance said, referring to a video of Walz that the Harris campaign posted to X on Aug. 6. “He said, ‘We shouldn’t allow weapons that I used in war to be on America’s streets.’ Well, I wonder, Tim Walz, when were you ever in war? What was this weapon that you carried into war given that you abandoned your unit right before they went to Iraq and he has not spent a day in a combat zone.”

In the video , Walz, who was campaigning for governor at the time, talked about pushing back on the National Rifle Association and said: “I spent 25 years in the Army and I hunt. … I’ve been voting for common sense legislation that protects the Second Amendment, but we can do background checks. We can do [Centers for Disease Control and Prevention] research. We can make sure we don’t have reciprocal carry among states. And we can make sure that those weapons of war that I carried in war, is the only place where those weapons are at.”

But, as Vance indicated, there is no evidence that Walz carried a weapon “in war.”

Update, Aug. 12: In an Aug. 10 statement to CNN, the Harris campaign told CNN that Walz “misspoke.”

“In making the case for why weapons of war should never be on our streets or in our classrooms, the Governor misspoke,” campaign spokesperson Lauren Hitt said in the statement. “He did handle weapons of war and believes strongly that only military members trained to carry those deadly weapons should have access to them.”

As we said, Augé, in her statement, said Walz’s battalion deployed “to support Operation Enduring Freedom” on Aug. 3, 2003, and “supported security missions at various locations in Europe and Turkey.” During his deployment, Walz was stationed in Vicenza, Italy, and he returned to Minnesota in April 2004, Augé said. There was no mention of Walz serving in Afghanistan, Iraq or another combat zone.

In the 2009 interview for the veterans history project, Walz said he and members of his battalion initially thought they would “shoot artillery in Afghanistan,” as they had trained to do. That didn’t happen, he said, explaining that his group ended up helping with security and training while stationed at an Army base in Vicenza.

“I think in the beginning, many of my troops were disappointed,” Walz said in the interview. “I think they felt a little guilty, many of them, that they weren’t in the fight up front as this was happening.”

In an Aug. 8 statement addressing his claim about carrying weapons “in war,” the Harris campaign noted that Walz, whose military occupational specialties included field artillery senior sergeant, “fired and trained others to use weapons of war innumerable times” in his 24 years of service.

Walz’s National Guard Rank

The Republican National Committee has criticized Walz for saying “in campaign materials that he is a former ‘Command Sergeant Major’ in the Army National Guard despite not completing the requirements to hold the rank into retirement.”

Walz’s biography on the Harris campaign website correctly says that the governor “served for 24 years” in the National Guard, “rising to the rank of Command Sergeant Major.” 

Walz’s official biography on the Minnesota state website goes further, referring to the governor as “Command Sergeant Major Walz.”

“After 24 years in the Army National Guard, Command Sergeant Major Walz retired from the 1-125th Field Artillery Battalion in 2005,” the state website says. 

Walz did serve as command sergeant major , but Walz did not complete the requirements to retire with the rank of command sergeant, Augé told us in an email. 

“He held multiple positions within field artillery such as firing battery chief, operations sergeant, first sergeant, and culminated his career serving as the command sergeant major for the battalion,” Augé said. “He retired as a master sergeant in 2005 for benefit purposes because he did not complete additional coursework at the U.S. Army Sergeants Major Academy.”

This isn’t the first time that Walz’s National Guard rank has come up in a campaign. 

In their 2018 paid letter to the West Central Tribune, when Walz was running for governor, the two Minnesota National Guard retired command sergeants major who criticized Walz for retiring before the Iraq deployment also wrote: “Yes, he served at that rank, but was never qualified at that rank, and will receive retirement benefits at one rank below. You be the judge.”

Correction, Aug. 9: We mistakenly said a 2007 “surge” strategy in Iraq occurred under President Barack Obama. It was President George W. Bush.

Editor’s note: In the interest of full disclosure, Harris campaign spokesperson Lauren Hitt was an undergraduate intern at FactCheck.org from 2010 to 2011.

Editor’s note: FactCheck.org does not accept advertising. We rely on grants and individual donations from people like you. Please consider a donation. Credit card donations may be made through  our “Donate” page . If you prefer to give by check, send to: FactCheck.org, Annenberg Public Policy Center, 202 S. 36th St., Philadelphia, PA 19104. 

Get the Reddit app

A subreddit dedicated to PhDs.

PhD culture: America vs Europe

I'm curious if anyone has insight about the culture if you're getting a PhD in America vs Europe. Specifically, I know from my experience so far in working toward a Phd in America, I'm not being paid enough to live on, I'm working 60-70 hours a week (last semester there were quite a few 80 hour weeks), and I'm expected to spend 80% or more of my work time on research even though I'm also expected to take 2-3 difficult and demanding classes a semester. Is this pretty typical in European PhD culture too?

By continuing, you agree to our User Agreement and acknowledge that you understand the Privacy Policy .

Enter the 6-digit code from your authenticator app

You’ve set up two-factor authentication for this account.

Enter a 6-digit backup code

Create your username and password.

Reddit is anonymous, so your username is what you’ll go by here. Choose wisely—because once you get a name, you can’t change it.

Reset your password

Enter your email address or username and we’ll send you a link to reset your password

Check your inbox

An email with a link to reset your password was sent to the email address associated with your account

Choose a Reddit account to continue

For students

  • Current Students website
  • Email web access
  • Make a payment
  • iExeter (students)
  • Programme and module information
  • Current staff website
  • Room Bookings
  • iExeter (staff)
  • Finance Helpdesk
  • IT Service Desk

Popular links

  • Accommodation
  • Job vacancies
  • Temporary workers
  • Future Leaders & Innovators Graduate Scheme

New and returning students

  • New students website
  • Returning Students Guide

Wellbeing, Inclusion and Culture

  • Wellbeing services for students
  • Wellbeing services for staff
  • Equality, Diversity and Inclusion
  • Israel, Palestine, and the Middle East
  • Homepage challengers

Welcome to the University of Exeter

World class education and research in one of the most beautiful parts of the UK

Search for a course

US entry requirements

Virtual campus tours

Funding and Scholarships

Meet us in the USA

phd in us vs europe

3 year Bachelors Go straight to your major

phd in us vs europe

1 year Masters No GRE required

phd in us vs europe

Rated Gold in the Teaching Excellence Framework (TEF) 2023

phd in us vs europe

Scholarships available

phd in us vs europe

150+ countries on campus

phd in us vs europe

92% of graduates in or due to start employment or further study fifteen months after graduation HESA Graduate Outcomes Survey 2019/20

phd in us vs europe

The Times and Sunday Times Good University Guide & Complete University Guide 2024

phd in us vs europe

Russell Group Research intensive university

Delivering Green Solutions

Find out about Exeter’s leading work on positive tipping points and new Global Tipping Points Report in partnership with the Bezos Earth Fund.

Find out more »

phd in us vs europe

Aerial view of the Streatham Campus, Exeter

Students working on Streatham Campus, Exeter

The Harbour Lights fish and chip shop in Falmouth

Interior of Exeter Cathedral

A traditional pub in Falmouth

The Forum, Streatham Campus, Exeter

Swanpool Beach in Falmouth

Reed Hall, Streatham Campus, Exeter

A lecture taking place in the Alumni Auditorium, Streatham Campus, Exeter

Rooftop bar in Exeter

Exeter Cathedral, built in 1133

Shopping in Princesshay, Exeter

One of many festivals that take place at Falmouth harbour

Paddleboarding and kayaking in Cornwall

 The University of Exeter Women's Rugby Club celebrate a win

World-famous St. Ives, a short drive from the Penryn Campus

Cross Keys Cafe on St Luke's Campus, Exeter

Brentor Church, Dartmoor, Devon

Aerial view of Penryn Campus and the coast

St. Luke's Fitness Centre

No Guts No Glory,  a lovely independent plant shop in Exeter

A student outside a local shop on Magdalen Road, near St Luke's Campus, Exeter

St Luke's Campus, Exeter

Stepcote Hill, Exeter

Independent shops on Fore Street, Exeter

Exeter Cathedral

Historic Exeter Quayside

The Cathedral Green, Exeter

The River Exe, Exeter

Traditional architecture in Exeter

Geology students in Cornwall

Physics students on the Streatham Campus, Exeter

Legendary Pizzas at Exeter's On the Waterfront restaurant

Latest News

Connect with us

Twitter link

Information for:

  • Current students
  • New students
  • Alumni and supporters

Quick links

Streatham Campus

St Luke's Campus

Penryn Campus

Truro Campus

  • Using our site
  • Accessibility
  • Freedom of Information
  • Modern Slavery Act Statement
  • Data Protection
  • Copyright & disclaimer
  • Cookie settings

COMMENTS

  1. Doing a PhD in Europe vs. the US

    Across Europe, a three to four year PhD in common. In comparison, six years is the average time to degree in the US with many PhDs in the humanities taking seven or eight years to earn their degree. Thesis Topic. PhD candidates in Europe must choose their thesis topic and supervisor during the application process.

  2. 11 Secrets of a PhD in Europe vs USA that Matter

    In comparison, in the US, some students can fly through their PhD in 3 years with tremendous amounts of research, while others can take as long as 8 to 10 years to complete their PhD. There are different systems within Europe. In Sweden and other Scandinavian countries, a PhD takes 4 to 5 years and includes additional teaching duties.

  3. Is it true that it is easier to obtain a PhD in Europe than the US on

    This is markedly worse in Europe, but the US is doing everything it can to "catch-up." In the US, the better job market allows multiple paths to success if you'd like to forego the PhD, while avoiding an advanced degree in Europe condemns one to worse underemployment than is already seen there (read that a Masters(Europe) is a Bachelors(US)).

  4. PhD in Europe vs the US: What You Need to Know

    Two popular destinations for doctoral study are Europe and the United States. In this blog post, we'll discuss the differences between doing a PhD in Europe and the US, focusing on key factors such as qualification requirements, time to degree, teaching requirements, coursework, and comprehensive exams. Qualification Requirements: In Europe ...

  5. Comparison of European And US-based PhD Education

    The average cost of obtaining a Ph.D. in the US is $120,000 (for four years), while in Europe, it is £38,600. This means that the US university system is more expensive than in Europe. But ...

  6. 8 big differences between the US and UK PhD experience

    It's a different story in the US, where, according to the Survey of Earned Doctorates, students take an average of 5.7 years to graduate. 4. UK PhD fees tend to be lower. Fees err on the more ...

  7. Comparison of European And US-based PhD Education

    Time to complete a Ph.D. in a US-based vs. Europe PhD Education program . The duration for completing a PhD education is similar in both locations. In the US, the average is 4 years for a full-time program. In the UK, it is also an average of 4 years for full-time programs. Students can do it in longer or shorter times.

  8. PhD in USA

    Method of Study. The main difference between a PhD in the US and a PhD in Europe lies in the program structure. Whereas a European PhD essentially consists of a single phase lasting three to four years, an American PhD consists of three different phases, each with its own time frame.. Phase One - The first phase lasts approximately two years and focuses on building a basic foundation for the ...

  9. Comparing STEM PhD Requirements: US vs Europe

    European PhD programs are often state-funded or project-funded, showcasing a different model of financial backing that can influence the nature and focus of research. Conclusion The requirements for pursuing a STEM PhD in the US and Europe differ markedly in terms of educational prerequisites, program duration and structure, thesis expectations ...

  10. US vs Europe PhD

    Comparing STEM PhD Requirements: US vs Europe Understanding the differences in STEM PhD requirements between the US and Europe is crucial for aspiring researchers. This article aims to provide a clear comparison of these varying academic landscapes, helping students make informed decisions about their educational paths.

  11. PhD in the US compared to Europe

    The main difference between doing a PhD in the US and most other countries is the coursework component. In the US, there is usually a requirement that PhD student complete at least 2 years of coursework before they start their independent research. This means that a PhD in the US will take longer to complete.

  12. 5 key differences between American- and European-style PhD ...

    The most striking difference between an American and European economics PhD is the expected duration of the program. In the US, universities traditionally offer a five-year degree where the first two years are devoted to training, and the final three years are expected to be spent on independent research. At the end of Year 1, graduate students ...

  13. united states

    Students from Asia (especially from China and Korea) I met said that they prefer going to the US for a PhD, and Europe is only a second option because of less prestige. There are more "big name" and "elite" universities in the US (and the UK) than Europe. In continental Europe, basically the only places with an "elite" ring to their name are ...

  14. Comparing PhD from Europe VS USA: A Comprehensive Analysis

    Conclusion. Choosing between pursuing a PhD in Europe or the USA is a significant decision that requires careful consideration of various factors. Both destinations offer world-class education, research opportunities, and diverse academic environments. Europe boasts a rich academic heritage, structured programs, and generous funding opportunities.

  15. PhD in the US vs Uk vs Europe vs Australia! : r/PhD

    Choosing a phd program isn't that easy. I was looking for different programs and I found major differences in doing a phd in the US vs all other. In the US. ... The reason the USA is 5 years vs Europe's 3 years, is the first two years in the USA is the master's degree.

  16. Getting a PhD in the USA: A Complete Guide for International and

    PhD in the USA vs. Anywhere Else. The most fundamental difference between partaking in a PhD program in the United States and Europe is the structure of your studies. While the British and European universities tend to focus on the individual pursuit of your area of interest, schools in the States are more inclined towards helping you hone your ...

  17. Which is Better? PhD Programs in USA, Europe, China Or India ...

    Discover the best destination for your PhD! Join us as we compare and contrast PhD programs in the USA, Europe, China, and India. Explore academic reputation...

  18. PhD programmes Comparison: the US Vs Europe (Part 1)

    PhD programmes in Europe are less time-consuming than those in the US. For instance, the duration of a PhD in France, Norway, the UK, and Germany is three years. A three-to-four-year PhD is typical throughout Europe. In contrast, the US takes six years on average to complete a degree, with many PhDs in the humanities needing seven or eight ...

  19. PhD US vs Europe : r/PhD

    PhD US vs Europe . Need Advice I am actually quite curious about this. Im just a first year ubdergrad for now but i have a high interest in researching and teaching for my later career. ... make the move to the US after my bachelors to do the 5 years PhD programs there.. what draws me to the US is mostly that i saw the option of fully funded ...

  20. graduate school

    In all european countries starting a PhD requires having completed 5 years of study (european master degree), while in US it is in theory possible to start a PhD after 3-4 years of study. TAship is less common and far less stringent in most european countries than in US. Share. Improve this answer.

  21. PhD in Europe vs the US and it's aftereffects? : r/PhD

    Which I think is great. One disadvantage of doing your PhD in the US is that it can be significantly longer than in Europe. EU PhD programs are typically fixed length, "up or out" style. In the US, instead, you graduate when your advisor says you got enough publications and results...

  22. Europe: 20+ fully-funded PhD positions

    Discover a wide range of courses and programs at prestigious universities across Europe in disciplines such as chemistry, biological sciences, biochemistry, biotechnology, engineering, molecular biology, medical sciences, agricultural sciences, soil science, environmental science, water science, physics, mathematics, geosciences, computer science, industrial engineering, downstream processing ...

  23. Phd in US vs Europe

    Phd in US vs Europe | PhD in USA or PhD in Europe | Which one is better? - This lecture explains Phd in US vs Europe | PhD in USA or PhD in Europe | Which on...

  24. Attacks on Walz's Military Record

    "When the United States of America asked me to go to Iraq to serve my country, I did it," Vance said. ... and "supported security missions at various locations in Europe and Turkey ...

  25. PhD culture: America vs Europe : r/PhD

    During my PhD in the UK I worked a pretty standard 9-5, often less (excluding the occasional crunch deadline, and obviously during the write-up of my thesis). TLDR: in my opinion, doing a PhD in the UK is way easier and less stressful than in the US! In Germany you get a liveable wage (~1500-1600€ netto).

  26. US

    The University of Exeter and Tsinghua University have launched a jointly-awarded PhD degree programme in climate and environmental sciences which supports six students to be co-supervised between Tsinghua's Department of Earth System Science and Colleges at Exeter that conduct research on earth systems and environmental sciences. Read more.